What does JG vs other players on the roster have to do with Dobbs or Dormady? What kind of argument is that? I clearly said last year.Depends on what statistics are important to you. He was terrible in the red zone. Outside the top 100 QB's nationally in RZ passing. The O has never scored points effectively or moved the ball consistently with him. He has not led UT to more than 30 offensive points in a game vs an FBS opponent in his career.
For perspective, UT averaged 366 points per season in the 10 years prior to JG becoming the starter... and that's not good compared to UT's O's in the 90's. In the 3 years in which he has competed for the job and started... UT has scored 275 points per season. You cannot lay it all at his feet but you cannot ignore the HUGE drop off between Dobbs and anything JG has done since. For that matter, UT scored as many points in 4 games behind Dormady as they did in 7 behind JG.
JG had a significantly higher completion percentage, higher yards per attempt, more touchdowns, significantly higher rating. He's not competing against Dobbs or Dormady. He's competing against two qbs that completed less than 50% of their passes, and one that threw 2 interceptions in the endzone.
All you never JGers are so weird, I said an objective fact about him vs his competition, and you bring up Dobbs and redzone efficiency (like the other two were great). I didn't say he was some high level player or anything like that, just that he's going to start and his performance will determine how much he plays going forward.