AshG, You're clearly very bright, but your admitted weakness "have trouble with social cues " is spot on. Coming here to the place where logic is never considered, then tying to use it to make your point, is not rational. Also, your theory would be easier to follow if you abandoned those double-negatives too.
This idea of connecting vol fans and their angst about a coach, or lack thereof, to their political ideology is not fact based, but opinion oriented and that's okay, but don't try to make it something it isn't. I come here to escape politics, not bring it into the conversation. This is sports. We're fans. We don't have to use logic, and we rarely do. That's okay too.
I like CJP. But his team has under-performed this year. He should get the blame. The fan base has lost confidence in him and perception is now reality. If insufficient people stop believing in you, change is probably necessary, even if he can right the ship. Coaches won't desire working here and players will seek better environments.
A contract is a contract and I would not advocate taking any of his pay away. But if he wants to stay, he needs a bold gesture to start with. Voluntarily giving up part of his salary may be one part of that, along with vocalizing his own failure. It would probably buy him some time but it needs to come from him, not UT. We're a forgiving people but the ball is in his court. If he wants to stay, he needs to ask for our help and stop being so thin skinned about the criticism. He's been his own worst enemy this year.
I personally think his attitude this year indicates he's changed and is no longer capable of that type of move. I don't like to advocate firing coaches, but unless he can bring the fan base on board with him, it's probably time to move on.