Is this true? Justine transferring

#4

Majors

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2020
Messages
8,458
Likes
11,647
#4
The one time Kellie actually gets a top flight HS recruit, she can’t keep her.

If she goes to another SEC school and balls out…oof
I’d say she ventures back up north. But you’re right, her one high school recruit and she didn’t handle it well. Committed for almost two years, either Kellie missed her evaluation - which was why she held on for so long or development lacked once she hit campus.
 
#6

And1

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 19, 2014
Messages
867
Likes
2,111
#6
I’d say she ventures back up north. But you’re right, her one high school recruit and she didn’t handle it well. Committed for almost two years, either Kellie missed her evaluation - which was why she held on for so long or development lacked once she hit campus.
Maybe she was recruited over by someone coming in?
 
#7

Majors

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2020
Messages
8,458
Likes
11,647
#7
Transferring may hurt her, and don't blame Kellie. She tried her best tto play everyone, but Justine didn't perform. She needs patience.
Didn’t perform or didn’t develope… enough “blame” to go around when your highest rated recruit can’t see the floor and opts to transfer after one year.
 
#10

volforlife10

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 21, 2019
Messages
746
Likes
2,331
#10
Top tier programs should always “recruit over”. We can say it’s not a HS school player…and if another portal player comes then it says more about the staffs lack of development to take another ready made player.
i disagree. hollingshead did not come in as a “ready made player.” she was practically a freshman. she barely played at georgia, so kellie and co. gets all the praise for her development and future development
 
#11

Raebo

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 29, 2018
Messages
1,153
Likes
1,947
#11
It’s bad for Tennessee but it is probably good for her if she is looking for a fresh start and maybe get a starting role this year. She has to be disappointed things didn’t work our here for her. Wish she could have gotten a lot more minutes last year.
I feel certain she was expecting to be a starter by this year but with RJ coming back, she realized that wasn’t going to happen.
 
Last edited:
#12

Volfan2012

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 11, 2012
Messages
28,472
Likes
43,954
#12
It’s bad for Tennessee but it is probably good for her is she is looking for a fresh start and maybe get a starting role this year. She has to be disappointed things didn’t work our here for her. Wish she could have gotten a lot more minutes last year.
I feel certain she was expecting to be a starter by this year but with RJ coming back, she realized that wasn’t going to happen.
I can feel another player coming in that could've had a part in the decision. I hope this is true and we announce a top player today.
 
#14

Voluble2

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 18, 2010
Messages
5,291
Likes
5,846
#14
I’d say she ventures back up north. But you’re right, her one high school recruit and she didn’t handle it well. Committed for almost two years, either Kellie missed her evaluation - which was why she held on for so long or development lacked once she hit campus.
This will make it even harder for Kellie to recruit high school kids.

Justine is a better player with a higher ceiling than some who got a lot more minutes this year while producing nothing. She needed playing time, and there was no downside to giving it to her given what we were getting at her position in a lot of games.

Kellie mishandled that situation badly. Her whole substitution and playing time scheme cost us a lot of games and now it cost us her only blue chip recruit.
 
#16

sisaq

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 1, 2015
Messages
3,586
Likes
4,652
#16
i disagree. hollingshead did not come in as a “ready made player.” she was practically a freshman. she barely played at georgia, so kellie and co. gets all the praise for her development and future development

Like you said, Hollingshead had been improving everyday, and it takes patience.
 
#18

And1

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 19, 2014
Messages
867
Likes
2,111
#18
I can feel another player coming in that could've had a part in the decision. I hope this is true and we announce a top player today.
The naysayers on this board (you know who you are) are reveling a little too much in their anti Kellie/Lady Vols rhetoric. We need some good news to kick them back down a couple notches.
 
#19

Majors

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2020
Messages
8,458
Likes
11,647
#19
i disagree. hollingshead did not come in as a “ready made player.” she was practically a freshman. she barely played at georgia, so kellie and co. gets all the praise for her development and future development
She barely played due to illness and knee injury. Played in 20 games, she wasn’t last on the bench handing out towels and handshakes. Also, ranked ahead of those in front of her already at TN. Again, ready made to play. Good get for TN but no need to act like we tapped into something.
 
#20

Majors

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 7, 2020
Messages
8,458
Likes
11,647
#20
This will make it even harder for Kellie to recruit high school kids.

Justine is a better player with a higher ceiling than some who got a lot more minutes this year while producing nothing. She needed playing time, and there was no downside to giving it to her given what we were getting at her position in a lot of games.

Kellie mishandled that situation badly. Her whole substitution and playing time scheme cost us a lot of games and now it cost us her only blue chip recruit.
Something me and coach jumper agreed on was this was Kellies test for future HS recruits, to look at how Justine was used as a freshman.
 
#21

VolFuture

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 20, 2022
Messages
742
Likes
1,337
#21
It’s bad for Tennessee but it is probably good for her if she is looking for a fresh start and maybe get a starting role this year. She has to be disappointed things didn’t work our here for her. Wish she could have gotten a lot more minutes last year.
I feel certain she was expecting to be a starter by this year but with RJ coming back, she realized that wasn’t going to happen.
Only see her starting on a bad team. Idk where she’ll go that she won’t be in the same situation unless mid major or bad P5 (but even then idk)
 
#23

Volfan2012

Well-Known Member
Joined
Aug 11, 2012
Messages
28,472
Likes
43,954
#23
She may be a wonderful person, but her performances this year were shockingly poor.
Airballed shots repeatedly, physically weak, no quickness and could not defend.
I hope she goes somewhere and enjoys her college days. Best wishes.
She played high school ball in a Catholic league that honestly didn't have a lot of talented players. She dominated in that league. I also have to give her some credit for some good AAU play as well when she played much better competition. She didn't really do anything here that was very good in the limited time she played. I would've worked her in a few more minutes if I had been in Kellie's shoes, but it is what it is good luck to her.
 
#25

glv98

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 21, 2018
Messages
4,674
Likes
14,500
#25
Maybe she was recruited over by someone coming in?
That was my thought. Otherwise the timing is weird. Why wait this long when the portal's been hellza poppin for a month? With the current roster, Justine was set to get alot of playing time, probably as primary backup to an All SEC player. That had to be pretty appealing.

Maybe it's not about playing time at all. Maybe homesick, misses twin, or something else is going on. Still hope it isn't true and wish her all the best if it is.

And time to put on the eyeshades, put in the ear plugs, you know where to put the cork. The Told You So Hallelujah Chorus bout to go on an endless loop. It is a very bad look, whether there was misevalution (lots of others had same mis eval) or lack of development, losing your first and only elite hs recruit is not good.

Even worse is the fact the LVs may not be able to field a team in a couple of years. Two empty classes is logistical roster damage that's going to take some real scrambling to fill.

I don't think it's all that damaging to the KJH's culture story. In the portal age, someone, esp near the end of the bench, is going to transfer. I still think the recent cultural wins outweigh this transfer if it happens.
 
Last edited:
Likes: Volfan1000

VN Store




Top