Stat wise, Ainge is in the top 5.
But if you had a choice between Andy Kelly, Heath Shuler, Tee Martin or Casey Clausen... or Erik Ainge, who would you take?
Let's not even bring Peyton, Tony Robinson or Conredge in the discussion.
I'll rank 'em in the order I would prefer to have them. This does not take into account the players who surrounded these players or the coaches who coached them...it's assuming they'd be competently coached and surrounded by the same decent talent:
1. Manning- Of course.
2. Robinson- My favorite Vol ever to watch and possibly the most raw talent ever behind center.
3. Shuler- The arm and running ability were a great combo.
4. Holloway- Never saw him in person, but his highlights are unreal.
5. Ainge- Great arm, very accurate...will make an NFL team very happy.
I don't rank Clausen or Kelly in the top 5 because they both had average to below average arms and Clausen seemed to be an attitude problem. Kelly threw more INT's than TD's in his career and was surrounded by more skill position talent than an QB ever at UT. Martin was a very erratic passer. He gets credit for winning NC, but that TEAM won the NC. Mostly the defense. There's a pretty good sized gap between Ainge and Martin.
Compare Ainge's WR's this year to what Kelly threw to (Pickens, Harper, Morgan, Woods) or even what Tee threw to (Price, Wilson, Parker, Martin) and you'll find they both got a lot more help than Ainge gets. Then consider who each handed off to (Cobb, Webb, Lewis, Henry). Despite all that, Ainge will end up with better #'s and a legitimate NFL career, which Kelly and Martin did not have.
No brainer...Ainge is a top 5 UT QB.