fossilfiction
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jan 5, 2012
- Messages
- 4,214
- Likes
- 7,533
Houston is a great coach. He won at The Citadel. Won everywhere he's been. He'll get a real job soon. Won't excite UT fans initially, but I think he'd actually be a great hire if we are not getting a "big name"
According to Sagarin, James Madison would be a 3 point favorite if we played them.
NCAAF Sagarin - NCAAF Football - USA TODAY
He has 2 FCS teams ranked higher than us. Let that sink in.
We've heard this before...
He does seem like a sound coach but I would prefer someone who has been a HC at a P5 school. This would be a major gamble.
Jim Tressel won national titles at Div II Youngstown State before going to OSU. Could do worse.
And they still play better football than UVA
georgia tech last Saturday. The Cavs aren't terribly good but they've got a pretty good coach, I think. They will go bowling this year, for what's that worth--and these days, with 40 bowls or whatever the number, it's not worth much.
You can't hire a Div. 2 coach. It would be embarrassing. It seems to me that it is the same small number of schools in contention for the FCS championship every year.
And fiery pre-game or halftime speeches are vastly overrated. The emotion disappears pretty quickly and then it comes down to how much talent do you have and do you execute--which has little to do with emotion. Motivation is always helpful, but x's and o's win football games.
The problem is we are coming off of a decade of non-competitiveness in our conference. Making a bargain hire and hoping that the coach replicate <insert non-P5 conference> success in the SEC is how we got into this mess in the first place.
... and listen to endless banter from a contingent here on VN about how $4 million is way too much money. They know Billy Bob at the rec center who won the county pee wee championship that would do it for $50 K and a six pack.
FCS success does not translate to the SEC. This would be a middle finger to the fans. I don't care if he is 19-1. This would be a horrible hire.
How foolish would we look if we offered and he turns us down????
With all respect for you, there's not much comparison between then two. Jones was the beneficiary of two weak schedules at Cincy. Nothing more. Had his second two schedules at Cincy been as tough as the first one... he never coaches a P-5 team and would have been fired by Cincy.
But you really can't just look at the regular season wins when judging an FCS team. That playoff adds quality opponents AND you have to beat them in consecutive weeks.Looking at JMU's 2016 regular season wins...
Moorehead State: 4-7
Central Connecticut: 2-9
Maine: 6-5
Delaware: 4-7
William & Mary: 5-6
New Hampshire: 8-5
Rhode Island: 2-9
Richmond: 10-4
Villanova: 9-4
Elon: 2-9
Only four opponents had winning seasons. Granted he did win out against better competition in the FCS playoffs, but he still benefited from terrible regular season opponents the same way Butch did at Cincinnati.