Will this finally settle the Manning - Brady debate?

#676
#676
butchna said:
Had his best stat year after.
Click to expand...
His wife also just coincidentally happened to have HGH delivered to their house, and Peyton's forehead just happened to get bigger that year, which is a whole lot closer to real cheating than anything Brady ever did.
 
#677
#677
Pump Guy said:
A 10-year-old kid won a science fair by proving Tom Brady is a cheater
Click to expand...
Lol, what debate? If your talking who is the better QB, there is no debate. And I am not hating on Manning. And I am not a pats fan. But Brady is the goat, Not the most talented, or the strongest arm. But he is the best ever. And has done it with average skill position players around him for the most part. And I understand why you guys might want to debate it. But don’t, it isn’t a good look. Brady Is The best ever with Montana a close second, and then it is a toss up between Manning and Elway. And again, not saying either of those guys were the most talented. Not even close really. But they are the best where it counts most.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Mtnvol80 and lifeisdeep
#678
#678
reecetn said:
LMAO switch away....

both instances (topics) the patriots were caught and punished for cheating. This thread is about the denial of said facts by you and countless others making excuses to save the sanctity of the poor pitiful patriots. Let us not forget this thread was started about a 10 year old kid trolling the super sensitive cheatriot nation.

look on the bright side at least you guys are not like the morons defending the treasonous ex secretary of state Hillary Clinton.

One last thing:

I am trying to figure out why you quoted the same post twice in one thread.

Who is drunk??????


View attachment 191308
Click to expand...
You'll lie about anything. Even when caught in a lie, as in when I pointed out in my previous post that I wasn't switching topics because you had specifically mentioned Deflategate in your post and I was merely responding to that. And then you continue the ruse that somehow I brought it up out of the blue.

Anyone who trots out a ten-year-old's science project that has no science to it, as evidence that Brady cheated, and then ignores the in-depth explanation from an MIT scientist on a very fundamental law of the properties of gases and how said law exonerates Brady, is just a willful liar. Even the basic premise of the kid's experiment, that deflated balls went further in the air, was "proven" by him and his super-sleuth parents in such a risible way that any real scientist would scold the parents and the kid's science teacher both: unless they propelled the balls with automatic throwing machines, which obviously they did not, they couldn't ensure that they used the exact same amount of force with their arms each time they threw a pass - which throws out the entire experiment. It's really not possible for an experiment to violate the scientific method in more ways than that kid's did.

But in the end, it just comes down to the fact that you know in your heart Brady is a better quarterback than Manning, or anyone else who ever played the position, but you're just a liar and a mocker so you come on here time after time to stir it up. You lie gleefully, as though it's a sport you can win a medal in, as though lies have no consequences. The scripture I posted a few posts ago was uttered by none other than Christ himself; I know you don't believe in God, but, genius, that doesn't make him not exist, or not hold you accountable for your life.
 
#679
#679
WiseOlVol said:
Wrong.
In G16 @ SD, he came off the bench late for a comeback to grab #1 seed.
In Semis v PITT, he engineered a 13 play 7 minute TD drive to win the game.
In the AFC-CG, he threw 2 TDs and had a 90.1 RTG for his 3rd AFC-CG win over Belichick/Brady (v 1 loss).
Brady threw 3 picks and had a 56.4 RTG.
PM did all of this with a career-ending injury.
The D won the SB, but they're sitting home without Manning's heroics in January.
Click to expand...

Defense gave up 20 points or less in every game you reference. And I still don't think Newton has recovered from that beating he took in the Super Bowl.

Manning deserves to be in the conversation as GOAT but that Broncos team was driven by the defense.
 
#681
#681
lifeisdeep said:
His wife also just coincidentally happened to have HGH delivered to their house, and Peyton's forehead just happened to get bigger that year, which is a whole lot closer to real cheating than anything Brady ever did.
Click to expand...

That’s it. Get off of this site now. You just lost the privilege of participating on volnation. That was over the line.
 
  • Like
Reactions: crovol
#682
#682
JonGrudensAgent said:
Defense gave up 20 points or less in every game you reference. And I still don't think Newton has recovered from that beating he took in the Super Bowl.

Manning deserves to be in the conversation as GOAT but that Broncos team was driven by the defense.
Click to expand...


Self destruction is actually fun to watch.

I need more gas

LMAO
 
#684
#684
lifeisdeep said:
His wife also just coincidentally happened to have HGH delivered to their house, and Peyton's forehead just happened to get bigger that year, which is a whole lot closer to real cheating than anything Brady ever did.
Click to expand...
Guy was this close to being paralyzed. IF he actually used the stuff, getting his arm barely back to NFL acceptable is the furtherest from cheating. And HGH is not an anabolic steroid. He always had a high forehead...not always the receding hairline.
 
  • Like
Reactions: JonGrudensAgent and reecetn
#685
#685
PhoenixAZVol said:
That’s it. Get off of this site now. You just lost the privilege of participating on volnation. That was over the line.
Click to expand...
The last I checked, that is not your decision. They try to have people with actual intelligence and honesty for moderators, which rules you out.
 
#693
#693
Bill Belichick would still win without Brady. Brady wouldn't win without Bill.

Manning carried a lot on his teams.
SB titles aren't the stick I judge with.
Same with other QB's such as Marino, Elway, Montana, etc etc
 
#694
#694
shotgun83 said:
Bill Belichick would still win without Brady. Brady wouldn't win without Bill.

Manning carried a lot on his teams.
SB titles aren't the stick I judge with.
Same with other QB's such as Marino, Elway, Montana, etc etc
Click to expand...
Belichick didn’t win without Brady...so not sure how that could be definitively stated.
 
  • Like
Reactions: crparker21 and lifeisdeep
#695
#695
Exiled said:
I can tell. Great comeback. Really showed off that superior intelligence. LOL at you, not with you.
Click to expand...
I have a master's degree from an Ivy league university; I have five degrees total, including a Ph.D. But I'm sure you can top that.

When I took the ASVAB, the Army's IQ test that everyone takes right before basic training, they wanted me to go into intelligence, i.e. be a spy for them. But again, I'm sure you scored higher.
 
#696
#696
lifeisdeep said:
I have a master's degree from an Ivy league university; I have five degrees total, including a Ph.D. But I'm sure you can top that.

When I took the ASVAB, the Army's IQ test that everyone takes right before basic training, they wanted me to go into intelligence, i.e. be a spy for them. But again, I'm sure you scored higher.
Click to expand...
You're so special! I'm sure your Mommy tells you that a lot.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big Al Orange
#697
#697
I don’t really care about this argument. Not even Brady would win games without a great offensive line. The secret to beating the Patriots has been out there since Brady blew out his knee and lost his mobility years ago. Pressure him up the middle by collapsing the pocket. Yet we have the freakin Pats in the Super Bowl for the 9th time in Brady’s career.
 
#698
#698
lifeisdeep said:
I have a master's degree from an Ivy league university; I have five degrees total, including a Ph.D. But I'm sure you can top that.

When I took the ASVAB, the Army's IQ test that everyone takes right before basic training, they wanted me to go into intelligence, i.e. be a spy for them. But again, I'm sure you scored higher.
Click to expand...

After I took the ASVAB they wanted me to be a Nuclear Engineer. I don’t like trains, so I passed.

That’s ASVAB as it gets.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big Al Orange
#699
#699
Exiled said:
You're so special! I'm sure your Mommy tells you that a lot.
Click to expand...
Do you have any strategy besides ad hominem? Since you're too stupid to know what that term means, it means resorting to personal insults when you know you can't win on logic or facts.

I wouldn't want to be you when Jesus returns.
Proverbs 19: 28-29
 
  • Like
Reactions: Exiled
#700
#700
Do you have any strategy besides ad hominem? Since you're too stupid to know what that term means, it means resorting to personal insults when you know you can't win on logic or facts.

I wouldn't want to be you when Jesus returns.
Proverbs 19: 28-29

Glad to see Google is your friend.

I'm not sure Jesus would approve of condescending, braggadocious, pompous diatribes, so you may want to read up a little. Thank you for your concern.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big Al Orange
New Posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

Advertisement



Back
Top