Vol8188
revolUTion in the air!
- Joined
- Mar 19, 2011
- Messages
- 48,343
- Likes
- 46,898
If you disagree with me, I would enjoy hearing your perspective and where you feel I'm mistaken. If you agree with me, perhaps these can be used help you in future conversations on the topic.
1. They will proclaim to reject "gender norms" or "gender stereotypes", yet their entire movement is based on both. For example if you were to ask "how did you know you were trans", you will get an answer like "I always liked pink and Barbies". Or if asked "how do you know gender is on a spectrum", they will start saying things like "some men are more emotional, some women are more dominate". So they are taking the same stereotypes and norms they claim to oppose and using them as defining principles within their own argument. They will openly pretend that any man who expresses historically feminine gender stereotypes is somehow less of a man (closer to a woman on their gender spectrum) and vise versa.
2. You cannot proclaim that sex and gender are different and then proclaim that men can get pregnant or that transwomen are women. You have to acknowledge that their sex is not the same as what they wish it were. This lie has gone so far that you can now fined/arrested in some countries and kicked off social media in the US for disagreeing with those statements.
3. They proclaim gender is on spectrum, but also a societal construct. If so, it would appear the majority of societies only have 2 genders. It's fair to proclaim it is a societal construct and you wish to redefine it (gender), but you cannot definitively proclaim that it is both a societal construct and infinite given that is not the way our society has historically seen the issue.
4. As Matt Walsh points out, their inability to define the terms man and woman or male and female. He went as far as to interview someone with a PhD in gender studies who is a professor at UT, who was unable to answer the question. Instead the professor said "A woman is a woman" or "a woman is someone who identifies as a woman". As early as elementary school we were all taught that you cannot define a term with the term itself. This professor studies gender, has a PhD in it, and lectures on the topic, yet is unable to define the most basic of terms within the topic he is a supposed expert in.
1. They will proclaim to reject "gender norms" or "gender stereotypes", yet their entire movement is based on both. For example if you were to ask "how did you know you were trans", you will get an answer like "I always liked pink and Barbies". Or if asked "how do you know gender is on a spectrum", they will start saying things like "some men are more emotional, some women are more dominate". So they are taking the same stereotypes and norms they claim to oppose and using them as defining principles within their own argument. They will openly pretend that any man who expresses historically feminine gender stereotypes is somehow less of a man (closer to a woman on their gender spectrum) and vise versa.
2. You cannot proclaim that sex and gender are different and then proclaim that men can get pregnant or that transwomen are women. You have to acknowledge that their sex is not the same as what they wish it were. This lie has gone so far that you can now fined/arrested in some countries and kicked off social media in the US for disagreeing with those statements.
3. They proclaim gender is on spectrum, but also a societal construct. If so, it would appear the majority of societies only have 2 genders. It's fair to proclaim it is a societal construct and you wish to redefine it (gender), but you cannot definitively proclaim that it is both a societal construct and infinite given that is not the way our society has historically seen the issue.
4. As Matt Walsh points out, their inability to define the terms man and woman or male and female. He went as far as to interview someone with a PhD in gender studies who is a professor at UT, who was unable to answer the question. Instead the professor said "A woman is a woman" or "a woman is someone who identifies as a woman". As early as elementary school we were all taught that you cannot define a term with the term itself. This professor studies gender, has a PhD in it, and lectures on the topic, yet is unable to define the most basic of terms within the topic he is a supposed expert in.
Last edited:
