wmcovol
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jan 10, 2012
- Messages
- 17,483
- Likes
- 30,716
I see something different just about every time. But… I will say, 9 times out of 10, that gets spotted as a 1st down. The Head Linesman shouldn’t be the closest official running in from 20 yards away
NCAA and NFL rules state that there is no penalty for a horse collar on a runner or passer within the tackle box. I didn’t know that until I looked it up after the game wondering how the refs missed that call. Turns out, they were correct on that call.Based on that video he absolutely made it. I've been on the fence until now. But it's clear he made it from that.
The refs missed a face mask and a horse collar in that drive, on Ole Miss, as well.
What pisses me off sooooo badly still to this day is that the Pig play was OVERTURNED! No way there was definitive evidence he lost control before it crossed the plane. We get ripped too much.Agree. But it’s kinda like the Pig Howard fumble against UGA a few years back. Every time I watch the replay, I’m more and more convinced it’s a TD. Same with Warren’s 4th and 24
This play was completely trash. It was totally meant to be a gadget play. Sell the fake hand off hard…look where the motion man ends up at. He’s by himself for a huge chunk play. The blitz comes from that same side so Corral gets blown up. He stands like a statue. Gets wrapped up then stripped in my be full motion of a full second. NOT ONE SINGLE OFFICIAL IS WAVING THEIR ARMS TO BLOW ANYTHING DEAD. 21 players are all going not even slowing up play. Not one damn person ever heard a whistle because it never happened.Total first down.
Didn't know that either. They still missed a face mask though.NCAA and NFL rules state that there is no penalty for a horse collar on a runner or passer within the tackle box. I didn’t know that until I looked it up after the game wondering how the refs missed that call. Turns out, they were correct on that call.
Unfortunately, the photo you shared is not when he was down. Here are two photos from the video you shared. The first clearly shows his knee is down well before his thigh hits. The second shows his thigh and elbow then hit. Your photo happens after these two photos. I don’t know where the ball was on the field when his knee hit, if it was a first down or not, but I do know the picture you used is definitely not when he was initially down.actually DID make the 1st Down Marker. The BEST view of this comes from the 19:17 mark of Ole Miss video just released from their sideline advantage.
HERE'S where the Ball was as Warren landed
View attachment 404825
HERE is the COMPLETE VIDEO...go to 19:11 seconds to begin the replays.
The Season: Ole Miss Football - Tennessee (2021) - YouTube
He didn't make it. And you're a clown. I doubt you'd call anyone an idiot to their face. Just another keyboard cowboy.
This is exactly what I’ve said. The problem was the optics of the call, created in part by bad mechanics of the side judge, and being way out of position. I know much has been said about the camera angle/lack of/or being torn up….but I think it was obvious that their initial placement was at least 1/2 yard if not a full yard off. If they had corrected the spot (which I think is somewhat doable with the video they had, understanding that the ball was in his mid section), and THEN remeasure…..I think it may have still been short of the line to gain, but I don’t think you have the throwing of objects onto the field at that point.I don't know if he made it. They missed the spot by at least a half yard. If they had changed the spot and measured and we still didn't get probably nothing happens.
Agree... although what kills me about these calls is the refs have no idea where it really was, it’s just their best guess. And then the cameras didn’t get a great view so they just stick with their guess.The spot was definitely horrible, but the ball was in the middle of his chest and not extended. Probably about 6” to a foot short.