Wall of text guy half your stuff is wrong.
Also I see you left off turnover rate since you want a percentage thing.
If responding to me... or even if you aren't... I have said all along that BM's INT's are a problem. He has to take care of the ball. I'm more OK with a Fr doing that than a RS Jr not finding plays down field... but it is a problem.
The other difference as I've said repeatedly is that I don't know if BM or Shrout is or can become the answer. Maybe neither can. I'm just pretty well convinced that JG isn't the answer. His flaws have been fatal to offensive production.
So even if you could prove that he was "better" than two Fr in their first few outings... he's still nowhere near good enough.
BM had literally one good quarter and then bad play.
BM literally moved the ball against UGA, MSU, and Bama. He literally threw for more than twice the yards JG did and at a higher completion %. He literally had significantly more ypc and ypa by about 30%. He threw INT's. Freshmen do. If they're trying they're going to make mistakes but you can have hope they'll be corrected.
JG is a RS Jr. The very fact that you have to twist the data as hard as you do to "prove" he's "better" than a true Fr... should tell you all you need to know.
You also want to explains away all BM turnovers and give him credit for drives.
Again, if you are talking to me... you need to read rather than that cult tactic of turning your brain off when someone starts to tell you your idol isn't perfect. JJ made a bad play. BM since getting real playing time has made 3 bad decisions/throws. There's no need to deny that. He's a Freshman and to a significant extent he makes up for it by producing twice the yardage per minute played than your idol.
I seem to remember a perfect pass in the endzone vs Florida that JJ turned into a int. So JG would have lead us to more points than the single fg we got with BM in.
Oooo... that was a great point.
Yeah. Mop up play with 2nd teamers is exactly like what a guy does when it actually matters. JG went what, 1 for 5 vs UGA in spite of hyper safe play calling? So what does that mean if your point about BM has any validity?
JG was pulled vs Bama for one stupid play. Not bad play overall. We were in the game and he kept driving us down the field.
JG was 44% with a 3.4 ypa against Bama. His "best" contribution in that game was the extent to which he managed the run game. Maurer in about a quarter was 5 for 7 and on target with every throw... even the one that turned into a INT. His ypa was 8.9.
They specifically playcalled AROUND him hoping they could win it without him losing it for them.
At least get your facts straight.
Facts.... straight. You? Not so much.