Mainly what you and a lot of other posters need to realize is that when you have depth and talent at certain positions, it is a great thing when freshman can't come in and start. Look at the Bama's and LSUs of the league. They don't start very many freshman or even second year players. Every year they have one or two that make a contribution but they are usually a combination of Really talented and at a thin position.
Brewer is a Senior. Randolph is a Sophomore stud. I just don't see McNeil beating either out with Moore and Wilks being behind them.
On to the others you mentioned in the quote above, Q will play in some specific plays designed for him and the return game. Meredith will only play due to us having no depth, but he has been banged up and even the coaches haven't been able to get a read on him so I don't know how you know he will play... Palardy sounds like he is doing better and Bullock had a horrible scrimmage. I don't think he beats out Palardy, but again if he does its not like
there is talent or depth at the position.