I have given my thoughts on the issue several times, at different times this season. I guess this is where I am currently at in my thinking.
There is something obviously very good about our offense. On the flipside, there is something atrociously bad about our defense. I did the stats a week or so ago, showing if we had a dead, middle of the road SEC defense according to the statistics this year, (I think around 22 ppg), we would have two losses. If we had last year's defense statistics, we would have 2 losses. So there is something to say about that.
Something that concerns me more than the losses, is how many players never seem to rise above their natural talents, suggesting coaching is lacking. You never see 3* players out playing the other guys, and so forth. Also, there are such mystifying things that you see on the field that just make you think something is wrong.
Bottom line, I think winning out, it is time to let Dooley go, although this may be unfair, there are enough red flags that make it seem like we will always be a year or two away from winning the games we need to win to be where Tennessee needs to be. This is a shame, but this is what I think.