Recruiting Forum Football Talk IV

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nick Foles did beat Tom Brady and Eli Manning beat him twice. Your argument is hypothetical. You have no idea what would happen if they switched teams, but you know what did happen… Tom Brady won 7 Super Bowls, beating some of the best quarterbacks in history along the way.
I know that if Tom Brady was behind the Chief's OL facing the Buc's DL in the SB last year, he probably wouldn't have made it out of half time, and he definitely wouldn't have won
 
I know that if Tom Brady was behind the Chief's OL facing the Buc's DL in the SB last year, he probably wouldn't have made it out of half time, and he definitely wouldn't have won

No QB in history would have. There’s an argument that Brady isn’t the most talented QB ever or that peak Brady vs peak any other top 5 QB could be a discussion. But the fact he holds pretty much every passing record, they amount of SBs and his longevity make it impossible to say he’s not on a different level
 
  • Like
Reactions: Maxwell865
Corral was kinda a bust before Kiffin got a hold of him. I hate me some Kiffin but he’s right up with Heupel as far as being a QB guru. So I’d expect Dart to flourish at Ol Miss.
Corral just got hurt his Freshman year. Definitely think Kiffin took him to the next level though
 
No QB in history would have. There’s an argument that Brady isn’t the most talented QB ever or that peak Brady vs peak any other top 5 QB could be a discussion. But the fact he holds pretty much every passing record, they amount of SBs and his longevity make it impossible to say he’s not on a different level
Of course he own every passing record. He played for 4 or 5 years longer than 2nd place. I'm more impressed that Peyton held them when he did than I am that it took Tom extra seasons to catch him.

Nobody said he's not great. But team wins do not equal individual goat. Without top 10 defenses every year, Brady doesn't win 7 rings. It was not Tom Brady who held his last two SB opponents to a combined 12 points.
 
Ok, going to disagree here and I believe Payton was better as far as a pure passer goes, but Brady wasn't "lucky" to win those SuperBowls. To get there he had to beat Manning, Rothlesberger, and the Ravens with Ray Lewis in his prime every year. Brady didn't have the strongest arm and wasn't the best pure passer, but his prep was second to none. He rarely made big mistakes and engineered scoring drives to win big playoff games in the last 2 mins over and over again against the Colts and Steelers. He played to his teams' strengths, made the right play calls, passed to the right people, and rarely made big mistakes. That wasn't luck.... I am a Steelers fan and hated playing Brady more than any QB.
Peyton is 3-1 against Brady in AFC Championship games.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Advertisement



Back
Top