This is indeed a tricky question and after some thought I say 5-7 with 5 close losses.
Here is my reasoning:
- As
@Enki_Amenra pointed out, close losses point better to a team that is close to a break through than blowouts
- Some point to recruiting would be better at 7-5, but I say pump the brakes...if we lose those 7 in very, very close games imagine the highlight sessions we will be featured in which double our exposure to recruits
- Also, exposure will be through the roof at 5-7 because when it gets to the playoff, every commentator will undoubtedly be bringing up the close games against the Vols that Bama, UGA, or Fla had to fight through
- I'm not generally one for 'moral' victories, but there is something to be said for 'morale' victories...it's easier to keep the morale up of a team that is right on the cusp of being successful than one that trots out and gets embarrassed in blowouts.
- I argue that recruiting will actually be better in the 5-7 scenario because the highly-ranked, competitive, hungry guy will look at that and say to himself there is a place I can make a one or two play difference and make them a winner