Orange Studs
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Jun 24, 2010
- Messages
- 25,663
- Likes
- 48,708
3rd down for what...He had a very strong record here.
National Scoring Defense:
Before arriving - 107th
2013 (Y1) - 78th
2014 - 34th
2015 - 16th
2016 (Shoop Y1) - 68th
3rd down defense
In 3 years:
2013 - 92nd
2014 - 16th
2015 - 2nd
He was undoubtedly a big success here. It does seem some have selective bias to remember a 4th down call or there (of which come about 10-20 times all season...TONS of variance) and ignore his huge volume of data of not just elite 3rd down defenses, but greatly improving scoring defenses.
I think your percentage of three star players is off. I think more than 2 in 227 players is rated a 3 star.0.9% of the players in the Superbowl are 5 star players.
20% of the players in the Superbowl are 3 star players.
0.01% of players are given a 5 star ranking out of high school.
0.44% of players are given a 3 star ranking out of high school.
Even with only one 5 star player in the Superbowl, 5 star players are over twice as represented in the Superbowl as 3 star players.
That isn't people science that's just basic math.
I think your percentage of three star players is off. I think more than 2 in 227 players is rated a 3 star.0.9% of the players in the Superbowl are 5 star players.
20% of the players in the Superbowl are 3 star players.
0.01% of players are given a 5 star ranking out of high school.
0.44% of players are given a 3 star ranking out of high school.
Even with only one 5 star player in the Superbowl, 5 star players are over twice as represented in the Superbowl as 3 star players.
That isn't people science that's just basic math.
Also, it's more like 60% are 3 star and below. I would personally rather have more 5 stars than 3 stars, but the points being made about evaluation AND development are critical to success because there are a very small number of 5 stars every year.0.9% of the players in the Superbowl are 5 star players.
20% of the players in the Superbowl are 3 star players.
0.01% of players are given a 5 star ranking out of high school.
0.44% of players are given a 3 star ranking out of high school.
Even with only one 5 star player in the Superbowl, 5 star players are over twice as represented in the Superbowl as 3 star players.
That isn't people science that's just basic math.
This is how you mathIn the math of stars, there are 30 five-stars out of high school every year, around 300 four-stars, and then everybody else. About 60% of five-stars get drafted and around 25% of four-stars get chosen. The average length of a career in the NFL is only 2.5 years. Obviously there are guys who last longer and guys who get dropped earlier, so this is the most recent average. Career length can also be influenced by position.
Anyway, using 2.5 years then that would be 75 high school five-stars, 45 of whom might make a NFL roster during that 2.5 year window. That’s about one and a half per team by the averages. There are around 188 out of about 750 four-stars in that period that the numbers suggest will get signed to an NFL roster. That’s around 6 four-star players per NFL team on average.
In that 2.5 year window there are approximately 41,000 draft eligible college football players across all divisions. Subtracting the 4 and 5 stars suggests that approximately 1,440 of the kids 3-star and under will make an NFL roster, around 45 per NFL team on average, or about 3.5% of the total eligible.
I have absolutely no issue with 3-star or lower rated players – but I have a strong preference for the kids that are going to end up in that 3.5% bucket. Let the other 96.5% go to Furman or Vanderbilt or Austin Peay or someplace. jmo.