The roster was as much a part of the discussion as coaching performance. Many were saying that the 2009 roster was better than the current one and using that as evidence that Kiffin and co. actually underperformed. I'm not necessarily disagreeing that he underperformed, especially in those games you mentioned. My point is that to be fair, that 2009 roster wasn't as great as a handful of stars make it appear to be.
Besides, you've got to consider roster when judging a coach's performance. Even Saban only managed 7 wins his 1st year at Bama, and that roster was probably better that '09 Vols.