That's like saying a DC can coach any defensive position. All coordinators coach all the mental aspects of positions, but every position has technical aspects that need a position coach who knows the technique of that position.
Surely you don't think any coordinator could easily coach any position just because he's a coordinator?
I didn't watch all of CMD's PC but what I did hear from him even if I was unsure about him as an OC I would feel a little better because I believe he has kept up with the game while he's not been coaching. He understands, probably better than anyone else, what Butch wants to happen with Tennessee's offense. Since only about 20% of posters on VN could be considered to be OC prospects it's doubtful that many of them would be qualified to coach Butch's particular offense. Also, since the other 80% of us could qualify as janitors that would put us in a position to know about CMD's actual expertise. JMO
I get the impression Butch knows he wants and he got it. I think everything will work out okay. Butch doesn't suffer fools well. He loves the passion of our fan base but it's lack of football knowledge annoys the crap out of him.
Imo Butch would not have hired a guy he didn't think could coach the position. With Nick Sheridan still there to help, Imo the QB coaching will be just fine.
I also think I read Butch brought in another kid who played QB for him before to help going forward.
What year did you graduate from Houston? I was '05. She ran off our cross country coach while she was there (about 2-3 years after I graduated) and coach Gibson won like 7 state championships in track and cross country and consistently had them ranked nationally. She's just an awful principal.
Coach Butch did go out of his way yesterday to make it clear that the term "spread" isn't a precise term. Then the new OC used the term several times to describe the offense the team will be running.
Caught that as well.
Again, they are both selling and are old hands at it (pun intended). DeBord knows this offense and that is what Butch wants to do. He doesn't want any new wrinkles, he wants to fully utilize what he has built over the years. It is a spread as most know on here. It is just that his history is that he runs more than he throws out of it when it is fully implemented like Mahlzahn does with his.
Butch knows he can throw the scent off the trail with a lot of fans by saying stuff since they seem to want to hang on every word he speaks. For what Butch believes and wants to do he made a good hire. Those of us that question it are having a hard time believing his offense can take the program to an elite level from what we have seen since he became a HC at CMU, not just since he has been at UT. However, most of us defer to him since he is the one that is paid to deliver the W's. We hope he knows what he is doing and will support him and the program 100%.