Top 20 coaches of all time

#1
YankeeVol

YankeeVol

Let's Geaux Peay
Joined
Mar 11, 2010
Messages
148,132
Likes
81,191
#1
From Herm Edwards:

1. George Halas
2. Vince Lombardi
3. Chuck Noll
4. Don Shula
5. Bill Walsh
6. Tom Landry
7. Bill Belichcik
8. Bill Parcells
9. John Madden
10. Paul Brown
11. Joe Gibbs
12. Mike Shanahan
13. Tony Dungy
14. Curly Lambeau
15. Tom Coughlin
16. Bud Grant
17. George Allen
18. Dick Vermeil
19. Marty Schottenheimer
20. Marv Levy

I think Gibbs should be higher.
 
#3
#3
Shula over Walsh?

hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha
 
#6
#6
The best two modern coaches were Walsh and Belichick in some order. And it's a long, long way down to #3.

I have no idea how to compare them to Halas and Lombardi because those two guys might have well have been cavemen clanking rocks together compared to what modern NFL coaches do.
 
#7
#7
Yup yup. Fame obviously wins out there, but the chances of them being chewed up and spit out in today's game are very high.
 
#8
#8
Does anybody else think Jimmy Johnson should be on this list?

Is it exclusive to the NFL? Would college resumes be factored in as well?
 
#10
#10
Maybe he doesn't deserve it on his NFL merits alone, but Marty Schottenheimer? I'd have Jimmy in over him. He's a good coach, but top 20?

Also, LOL at those idiot Chargers. I knew it was a mistake to fire him after a 14-2 season. What a joke.
 
#11
#11
How in the hell is Walsh not #1? The man changed the way offense was played.
 
#20
#20
dobre_shunka said:
So Walsh who coached up to 1988 is "modern" and Noll who coached up to 1991 isn't?
Click to expand...

The two factors that created the modern NFL were the salary cap and Bill Walsh himself. Chuck Noll's success came in the prehistoric era.


dobre_shunka said:
Walsh - 3 Super Bowl Wins
Belichick - 3* Super Bowl Wins
Noll - 4 Super Bowl Wins

It's a long way "down" from 3 titles to 4?
Click to expand...

Was Terry Bradshaw a greater quarterback than Tom Brady?
 
#22
#22
I like his better.

20. Dan Reeves
19. Ray Flaherty
18. Tom Coughlin
17. Marv Levy
16. Hank Stram
15. George Allen
14. Jimmy Johnson
13. Sid Gillman
12. Curly Lambeau
11. Bud Grant
10. John Madden
9. Chuck Noll
8. Bill Walsh
7. Don Shula
6. Tom Landry
5. George Halas
4. Bill Belichick
3. Paul Brown
2. Joe Gibbs
1. Vince Lombardi
 
#23
#23
The thread is titled "Top 20 coaches of all time"


Vercingetorix said:
The two factors that created the modern NFL were the salary cap and Bill Walsh himself. Chuck Noll's success came in the prehistoric era.
Click to expand...

1979 is "prehistory" and 1981 is "modern"?

Vercingetorix said:
Was Terry Bradshaw a greater quarterback than Tom Brady?
Click to expand...

Brady wouldn't have the same stats if he played in the era of bump and run coverage. Brady wouldn't have finished a single game if he had to absorb the hits QB's like Bradshaw did instead of being explicitly coddled by the NFL rules of today.
 
#25
#25
Yankee_Vol said:
I like his better.

20. Dan Reeves
19. Ray Flaherty
18. Tom Coughlin
17. Marv Levy
16. Hank Stram
15. George Allen
14. Jimmy Johnson
13. Sid Gillman
12. Curly Lambeau
11. Bud Grant
10. John Madden
9. Chuck Noll
8. Bill Walsh
7. Don Shula
6. Tom Landry
5. George Halas
4. Bill Belichick
3. Paul Brown
2. Joe Gibbs
1. Vince Lombardi
Click to expand...

Shula over Walsh??????

hahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahahaha


Did people just forget Bill Walsh won four SB's in eight years and changed football forever or something?
 
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.
Advertisement



Back
Top