Seriously, stop tweeting players

[volfannbama]

Overall yes. Better system by better coaches.
No he didn't make the Broncos defense better. No question he got a bit of a ride the last few weeks of his career. However, throughout his career, both in college and the pros, he made the players he worked with directly, better and many were more successful as a result. (probably too many commas)
If I was rebuilding a team, and needed a franchise QB to build around and could take either in each of their respective primes. It wouldn't take me one second to select Peyton.

Brady doesnt make the players around him better?

 

[jakez4ut]

Manning is properly rated....


As the second best QB of all-time

agreed.

 

[Wylo]

The difference between Manning and Brady is that Manning made the players and coaches around him better and Brady's players and coaches made him better. GOAT? I don't know but, 5 SB rings don't tell the whole story.

You.cannot.be.serious.



Peyton had hall of fame talent around him. Brady had Moss briefly(no super bowl win) and Gronk.....


The coach is far in Brady's corner, but that is it.


It's not even close.

 

[basspond]

You.cannot.be.serious.



Peyton had hall of fame talent around him. Brady had Moss briefly(no super bowl win) and Gronk.....


The coach is far in Brady's corner, but that is it.


It's not even close.

I would think think that there is a possibility that the 5 Most Valuable Player awards given to Manning (on both teams he played for. Plus a Pro Bowl team) would speak to a general opinion that he was more valuable to his teams. Doesn't this imply that without him the team would not be as good??

 

[GoVolunteers]

Brady is a great player. But, I like how all of the arguments on his side come from TEAM accomplishments. He had a greater CAREER than Peyton because of those team accomplishments. But, they don't necessarily make him a greater QB.

Peyton took four different coaches to the Super Bowl, only one of which was worth a d@mn. That says more to me than a QB who went to more playing for the greatest HC of all time.

Just my opinion.

Ok I found one of the tweeters