I was counting "recruited" scholarship WRs. I may be wrong, but I don't think Winton and Weary are on scholarship. But yeah, they would be 8 and 9, if it got that far.
But getting more into that depth conversation...
Truth is, for all those worried about lack of bodies, we've never used more than 4 or 5 in meaningful minutes. Some of the same fans who criticized the staff for not playing many WRs are now gnashing teeth over lack of WR depth.
2021: we pretty much exclusively stuck with Tillman, Jones, and Payton. They tried getting Calloway and Hyatt on the field in spots early in the season, but they weren't reliable, so we went with the 3 man rotation.
2022: Tillman, Hyatt, and McCoy were the 3. Then Tillman got hurt against Ohio and Keyton took his place. Squirrel actually rotated in some later in the year as a freshman, but not really because he was needed, but more because Tennessee was way ahead (Orange Bowl being the exception). Those 5 were the only WRs who got meaningful snaps.
2023: McCoy, Squirrel, and Keyton were the 3. Then McCoy got hurt in late September and Nimrod became the 3rd. No one else really played meaningful snaps that year. Webb got in some, but it wasn't during meaningful moments, so it was pretty much 4 who played meaningful snaps.
2024: Started out the season with McCoy, Squirrel, and Thornton, with Brazzell as the 4th. Nimrod rotated in some. McCoy, Squirrel, and Thornton all dealt with the injury bug throughout the year, and yet, we still didn't play anyone other than those 5 in meaningful minutes, with one exception...Matthews against Vandy. So 2024 was the year we needed to go furthest down the depth chart (due to numerous injuries) and that was to the 6th guy (Matthews who had passed Webb on the depth chart by then).
I think this year's group is much more talented than last year's, just inexperienced. Our big 3 will be Matthews, Staley, and Brazzell. If we have to go to a 4th, it will be Travis Smith, who is the most talented freshman WR we've had under Heupel. If a situation like 2024 materializes, and we have to go to a 5th, it's likely Rad Jackson (possibly Jefferson). And if that situation materializes, it's at the end of the year and the freshmen will be much more comfortable.
The gnashing of teeth over lack of WR depth is overblown. It's simply about the unknown. The unknown scares people, but the truth is, our WRs weren't good last year. Neither was Nico. I'd rather have unknowns with promise than known quantities that are mediocre.