RANK SEC FOOTBALL COACHES (Merged)

#51
#51
VolinArizona said:
And Brooks? I'd rather have a successful position coach who has already recruited well, than a coach who has never won with any consistency.
Click to expand...

Like I said, I was not trying to make a huge deal of it either way. Brooks did beat Orgeron on the field.
 
#53
#53
Fulmer, just to be honest, is about the last guy I want in a big game for all the marbles. That's not a shot, but just an observation. Take out the horseshoe year and what do you have? A bunch of really talented teams that didn't win anything.
Click to expand...

That sums up my feelings. 5-10 against top 10 teams at home since 2000 confirms it, along with two SEC CG losses (Auburn was better but Lsu wasnt).

To the coaching list...

1. Richt. Awesome recruiter, great playbook, teams dont give up (last year's sugar bowl), physical defenses

2. Spurrier. Would have been #1 a couple years ago, but it seems like his offense isnt nearly as effective. Of course a lot of that has to do with the players he has, but I still wonder if the SEC hasnt turned the corner on his offense. His last couple fla years were underachieving for the talent he had.

3. Tommy T. Has dominated the west with less talent then Alabama and Lsu.

4. Mike Shula. He's young and has done well considering a program coming off probation. Makes the most out of the lack of offensive talent.

5. Urban Meyer. I dont like how he threw his rb's under the bus, but his offense is unorthodox and hard to defend. If he can make Alex freaking Smith a heisman canidate, he knows how to coach.

6. Croom. Should have been coach at bama.

7. Fulmer. I just dont think that highly of him. He struggles with the big games, his teams fold at home against top opponents, we average about a blowout loss a year now which is unacceptable for a team with the talent we have, other programs (uga) have made inroads on recruiting. Yes he won the title but look at the players we had...pretty hard for that team to lose more then two games max.

8. Houston Nutt

9. Les Miles. They should be running over everyone with the talent they have.
 
#54
#54
TravisHenryCBlockedMe said:
That sums up my feelings. 5-10 against top 10 teams at home since 2000 confirms it, along with two SEC CG losses (Auburn was better but Lsu wasnt).

To the coaching list...

1. Richt. Awesome recruiter, great playbook, teams dont give up (last year's sugar bowl), physical defenses

2. Spurrier. Would have been #1 a couple years ago, but it seems like his offense isnt nearly as effective. Of course a lot of that has to do with the players he has, but I still wonder if the SEC hasnt turned the corner on his offense. His last couple fla years were underachieving for the talent he had.

3. Tommy T. Has dominated the west with less talent then Alabama and Lsu.

4. Mike Shula. He's young and has done well considering a program coming off probation. Makes the most out of the lack of offensive talent.

5. Urban Meyer. I dont like how he threw his rb's under the bus, but his offense is unorthodox and hard to defend. If he can make Alex freaking Smith a heisman canidate, he knows how to coach.

6. Croom. Should have been coach at bama.

7. Fulmer. I just dont think that highly of him. He struggles with the big games, his teams fold at home against top opponents, we average about a blowout loss a year now which is unacceptable for a team with the talent we have, other programs (uga) have made inroads on recruiting. Yes he won the title but look at the players we had...pretty hard for that team to lose more then two games max.

8. Houston Nutt

9. Les Miles. They should be running over everyone with the talent they have.
Click to expand...
In a shocking development, I'll have to defend TCHFCATUTK. There is no rational reason anyone could rate Sylvester Croom ahead of TCHFCATUTK. Croom's only head coaching experience consists of taking a bad situation and making it exponentially worse.
 
#57
#57
1. Bear Bryant
2. Wallace Wade
3. Frank Thomas
4. Gene Stallings
5. Mike Shula
6. Ray Perkins
7. Bill Curry
8. Dennis Franchione
9. Mike Price
10. Mike Dubois
 
#58
#58
I just read this article in "Rocky Top News" a few days ago. If my Memory is correct they had them listed.

12 Coach O
11 Croom
10 Morris
9 Johnson
8 Shula
7 Nutt
6 Myer
5 Miles
4 Fulmer
3 Spurrier
2 Tommy "cry baby" Tub.
1 Richt
 
#59
#59
correct me if im wrong but isnt fulmer the 2cd winningest sec coach(active)......lol once again another reason why i dont post or visit as much as i used too........way too much critisim, but most of you will argue thats what the message board is for, well yeah but seems like the florida fans in here give tennessee more respect then a quite a few "VOLS" fans......THATS SAD
 
#60
#60
TennVols423 said:
correct me if im wrong but isnt fulmer the 2cd winningest sec coach(active)......lol once again another reason why i dont post or visit as much as i used too........way too much critisim, but most of you will argue thats what the message board is for, well yeah but seems like the florida fans in here give tennessee more respect then a quite a few "VOLS" fans......THATS SAD
Click to expand...
Just rate the current SEC head coaches based on who you would hire if you were the AD and your school had to fill that position, NOW, not eight or ten years ago.

I agree there is a thread just for Fulmer bashing or Fulmer idolaltry to use for negative personal comments as you mentioned.
 
#62
#62
1. Urban Meyer
2. Urban Meyer
3. Urban Meyer
4. Urban Meyer
5. Urban Meyer
6. Urban Meyer
7. Urban Meyer
8. Urban Meyer
9. Urban Meyer
10. Steve Spurrior
:neener2:
 
#63
#63
gatorfan29 said:
1. Urban Meyer
2. Urban Meyer
3. Urban Meyer
4. Urban Meyer
5. Urban Meyer
6. Urban Meyer
7. Urban Meyer
8. Urban Meyer
9. Urban Meyer
10. Steve Spurrior
:neener2:
Click to expand...
Note to self . . . If I ever go to troll on a rival message board, take steps to correctly spell the name of the most successful coach in school history.
 
#65
#65
In the SEC.
Meyer
Spurrier
Richt
Tubbervile
Saban
What order you put those in is debatable, but no one can argue that they would take Fulmer over any of those coaches. I don't think it's a coincidence that we are now the 5th or 6th best program in the SEC.
 
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.

VN Store



Back
Top