Please replace Max Gilbert

How about the Georgia game? We would be in the playoffs if it wasn’t for him.
Please stop blaming that loss on the kicker. Everyone knows we lost that game when coaches tried to run out the clock after we recovered the fumble. Coaches played not to lose instead of going for the win. Your whole premise is that any kicker we get MUST never miss especially when a lead/game is on the line. That is insane besides not being realistic.
 
Teams all over the the country have guys who can drill 50 yarders and he sucks outside of 40. And he’s the opposite of clutch.

All of his makes that puff his stats were 30 yarders last year when we stalled out in the red zone over and over again. He doesn’t mentally have it.
True. This isn’t 2000 anymore. It’s crazy we’ve struggled to land one of these guys the last decade.. meanwhile Missouri’s had about 5 of them.

The whole most accurate kicker thing was extremely misleading as well. He’s had a lot more kicks and a lower yards per kick on his attempts.

That being said, the UGA loss wasn’t on him as much as it was on Banks/Heupel.
 
How about the Georgia game? We would be in the playoffs if it wasn’t for him.
We could have made the playoffs if our All-american CB wasn't playing hookie. (IDGAD what Brent and Austin keep saying)
Gibson hurt.

Joey throwing 2 picks with his 3 TDs.

Heupel being a scared little (you know what) at the end of the 1st half

Plenty of blame to go around that game
 
We could have made the playoffs if our All-american CB wasn't playing hookie. (IDGAD what Brent and Austin keep saying)
Gibson hurt.

Joey throwing 2 picks with his 3 TDs.

Heupel being a scared little (you know what) at the end of the 1st half

Plenty of blame to go around that game
💯 this!!! It is easy to blame Max for the loss but there were multiple reason we lost that game with the final reason being the missed FG.

I would argue the biggest play that derailed our playoff hopes was the Sanders missed block and Joey’s fumble. I believe if we had went up 14-0 on Oklahoma we blow them out but no one is screaming to kick either Sanders or Joey off the team as they shouldn’t.
 
  • Like
Reactions: LittleVol
We also need QBs that never miss their targets, receivers that never drop passes, O lineman that never miss a block, defenders that are always in position and never miss a tackle, backs that never fumble, etc........
 
Last edited:
Don't forget OU he missed 2 we lost by 6
Looks like you're the one who forgot. He was 2-3 against OU.

Further, he was 2-2 against Arkansas, including 1 from 50+ and Tennessee won by 3. But I guess those weren't "clutch kicks" that "Mattered" because he made them.
 

Attachments

  • Screenshot 2025-11-23 at 9.22.05 AM.png
    Screenshot 2025-11-23 at 9.22.05 AM.png
    141 KB · Views: 2
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: Tenacjim
Advertisement





Back
Top