"Peyton never had a defense worth a crap."
I wouldn't go that far, but in those big games against Florida, the defense may as well have been eating hot dogs on the sideline. Spurrier's offense was that far ahead of them. They shredded us, every year.
Which plays against Peyton's greatest weakness... when things are going badly, and his defense doesn't seem like it can stop the other team's offense, Peyton tries to do too much. Still does to this day.
That being said, if Manning had played perfectly, we wouldn't have beaten Florida. Between the defense being turned into garden mulch, receivers dropping passes, and Jay Graham diving over the pile and fumbling the ball (and all those similar plays), there's just no way. Florida had us by the mental short & curlies back then.