on a serious note...you can't argue the star factor in recruiting...i'm betting he could close pretty well. just a guess. x's and o's don't worry me at all, in fact, there's nothing strictly football related that would worry me.
i think Gruden could and would put together a really good, if not great, staff.
i think Gruden is a great match up finder, and i think from a game planning standpoint, you'd be hard pressed to convince me he couldn't do that as good, or better, than most anyone we went up against.
there are drawbacks though. i think he'd be uber dependent on his staff for all the "college" stuff....i'm not sure he'd love recruiting or the restrictions on football 'student athletes' face. i don't think the Big Orange Caravan would be #1 on his list of things to do in other words.
being a head coach at a program like this is a lot more than the x's and o's. and i think gruden weighs that against what he really does love...and that's the x's and o's. plus, the roster turnover you have to experience in college makes it difficult to consistently do the things you might want to do. on the plus side, i'd find it hard to believe he'd NOT be a great evaluator and developer of talent. but does he have the patience to do so, all the freaking time?
i think the positives outweigh the negatives. and the negatives can be overcome, assuming he's in the right place mentally speaking, and with a good staff around him that can navigate the stuff he doesn't like.
i'm only at about 40% chance he comes here, so i don't think it's much of an issue when all is said and done.
but, if you can really get him....do it.