I do, yes. Not that I don't see room for disagreement, I think you raise a very fair question. But I think the stats, along with the tried and true "eye test" still come out pretty massive in Bama's favor.
Alabama achieved 3 playoff wins, 3 national title appearances, and a combined 5 losses in the last 4 years.
That Clemson group accounted for zero national title appearances, a 70 point loss to WVU, and lost a combined 10 games (while in the ACC).
Tajh vs. Tua best year comparison
Tua 43 TD, 6 INT, 5 Rushing TD, 69% completion, 3966 yards
Tajh 34TD, 11 INT, 10 Rushing TD, 68% completion, 3851 yards
WR 1 Comparison (best year)
Jeudy 14 TD, 1315 yards 19.3 avg (with 1 game left)
Hopkins 18 TD, 1405 yards, 17.1 avg
WR 2 Comparison (best year)
Smith 13 TD, 1200 yards, 18.5 avg (with 1 game left)
Watkins 12 TD, 1464 yards, 14.5 avg
WR 3 Comparison (best year)
Waddle 7 TD, 838 yards, 18.8 avg (with 1 game left)
Bryant 7 TD, 828 yards, 19.7 avg
WR 4 Comparison (best year)
Ruggs 11 TD, 741 yards, 16.1 avg (with 1 game left)
Humphries 2 TD, 483 yards, 11.8 avg
RB Comparison (best year)
N. Harris 11 TD, 1088 yards, 5.9 avg (with 1 game left)
D. Harris 11 TD, 1000 yards, 7.4 avg
B. Scarbrough 11 TD, 812 yards, 6.5 avg
A. Ellington 11 TD, 1178 yards, 5.0 avg
R. McDowell 5 TD, 1025 yards, 5.4 avg
*Not that McDowell was comparable, but Clemson's 3rd best back didn't even deserve to be in this conversation.
I think the consensus can be - they both have been pretty stacked with talent, and depending on who you ask, you may get a different answer.