It's always interesting to hear the opinion of Ohio State from those living outside the state. I don't know if I've ever heard a good thing about the Buckeyes from anyone living outside Ohio. For me, I grew up an OSU fan. My dad took me to games every year and I loved it. They've got a great stadium, nice campus, and wonderful tradition. Then I went to college in Cincinnati and discovered, for the first time really, what today makes me not root at all for OSU: the fans. I don't mind their conference (although it's like watching paint dry) and I think they've been remarkably successful outside bowl games in the last few years. But the fans are out of control. It's not really even that they have high expectations. They do, but what makes them intolerable is that they live in a big bubble. When they win, they're the greatest team on earth. When they lose, the refs sucked or there were injuries. I like Tennessee fans because the expectations are high but for the most part, you all seem to be well versed on football and realistic with those expectations. Most UT fans I talk to say, "hey, we're in a great conference and we've got some of the finest tradition offered, and we'll always compete, but in the last few years, maybe we haven't been quite where we hope to be. If this happens or that happens, hopefully it'll get us back to perennial top five-dom." I'd wager that most OSU fans can't name five teams outside their own conference. Whenever I tell one of them that college football is passing their team and their conference by, they look at me like I'm speaking french. So I can't say I hate OSU considering how long I rooted for them as a kid, but I effing hate their entire fanbase, with few exceptions.
I'm a Bearcat fan through and through, so I passionately dislike West Virginia and Pittsburgh more than any. WVU because they're overrated every year, and Pitt for their fanbase.