Is Dobbs the best SEC QB in 2016?

#202
#202
KBVol said:
We're "creating great bump able material"?? Haha. Jeez dude, you're absolutely obsessed with Josh saying things like he's a guaranteed heisman finalist and sure fire first rd NFL pick....and you're NOT creating bump able material? Lol.

I'm anything but anti Dobbs. If you'd honestly read through a number of threads on here rather than get your feelings hurt when anybody mentions Dobbs' accuracy issues, you'd see that I consistently defend him...and I do it with the statistics (you know, those pesky things that by and large are the best indicators we have that define a player's performance) that you want to marginalize and denigrate.

I think Josh, who was middle of the pack throwing the ball in the SEC this year, was a top 4 QB in the league behind Prescott, Allen and Kelly, and projects to be the second best QB in the conference behind Kelly next season....you know, ahead of the 12 other starting qbs in the SEC....boy that's really running him into the ground and worthy of you putting my posts in the D4H archives to be pulled out and bumped this time next year. And trust me, the more you keep incessantly pushing this, the more clearly it looks to everybody who's stupid on here.
Click to expand...

Oh I know I'm creating bump worthy material. But I'm gonna be right. It'll only make me look like a genius. You'll be the one looking foolish with how wrong you'll be.
 
#203
#203
Dobbs 4 Heisman said:
Oh I know I'm creating bump worthy material. But I'm gonna be right. It'll only make me look like a genius. You'll be the one looking foolish with how wrong you'll be.
Click to expand...

I'm starting to think you've got some type of parody going on. I'll gladly tip my hat if your Dobbs predictions come true because it'll likely mean we find ourselves in Atlanta in early December with a chance to be one of the last 4 standing. But I'll go on record here that I just don't see another 1,000 yards and another 15 tds passing for Josh, even if he does make great improvement.
 
#205
#205
KBVol said:
I'm starting to think you've got some type of parody going on. I'll gladly tip my hat if your Dobbs predictions come true because it'll likely mean we find ourselves in Atlanta in early December with a chance to be one of the last 4 standing. But I'll go on record here that I just don't see another 1,000 yards and another 15 tds passing for Josh, even if he does make great improvement.
Click to expand...
I think everyone is hoping that he does
 
#207
#207
Casey Clausen was twice the QB Dobbs is,I give it to Dobbs he can run but that's it he cant pass a lick he couldn"t hit the ocean standing on the beach In destin!
 
#208
#208
Dobbs is only our QB because he's the sole veteran QB in the system and we need a somewhat mobile QB to even have a puncher's chance when our schotty OL gives way.

I would bet that if Dormady, Jones or even JG had been in the system 3 full years then Dobbs would be riding the pine. Kid has some talent but there are a number of guys that come through the ranks every year that are as equally as talented, if not more so. So to think that Dobbs is a "once in a decade" type player is completely ignorant. You're either related to Dobbs or sleeping with him if you think that.

Can Dobbs improve a smidge next year? Absolutely.

Can he improve so much that he's a 3,000+ yard passer with 30+ TDs and > 60% Completion Pct.? Magic 8 Ball says, "Extremely Doubtful".

IF anyone from UT wins the Heisman next year it will be Hurd. End. Of. Story.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#209
#209
Dobbs could very well lead however thats not saying much other than the SEC being weak at that position. Dobbs is a bit overrated. Dont like saying it but its the truth. Some Vols love him some look at whats real about him. Once he learns to throw the ball deep and puts accuracy into it then it will be a different story and Dobbs isn't the best since Manning sorry bout it. Still would take Clausen before him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#210
#210
Vfledits said:
Dobbs could very well lead however thats not saying much other than the SEC being weak at that position. Dobbs is a bit overrated. Dont like saying it but its the truth. Some Vols love him some look at whats real about him. Once he learns to throw the ball deep and puts accuracy into it then it will be a different story and Dobbs isn't the best since Manning sorry bout it. Still would take Clausen before him.
Click to expand...

Say what you will but we would not be 8-4 without him.
 
#211
#211
Beginning next year, I think we become like Ala. has been for the last 15 years. We can put anyone in at QB and we will win. Ala. has very rarely had an NFL caliber qb but they are always playing for NC. Dobbs, Dormady, and JGar will all have their chance at sending us to the promised land for the next 5-6 years!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#212
#212
Purplehaze26 said:
Beginning next year, I think we become like Ala. has been for the last 15 years. We can put anyone in at QB and we will win. Ala. has very rarely had an NFL caliber qb but they are always playing for NC. Dobbs, Dormady, and JGar will all have their chance at sending us to the promised land for the next 5-6 years!!
Click to expand...

I'll save someone the trouble. "Don't sleep on Sheriron". :pinch:
 
#213
#213
KBVol said:
Surely you're not trying to make the case that Kelly isn't as good as Josh because his team lost one game (a game in which he threw for 372 yds and completing 70%to a pretty good Memphis team. It's along the lines of posters who want to try and convince people that Tee Martin, a career 55% thrower, was a great QB/passer at Tennessee because of the completion % record vs a 1-11 SCar team.

Kelly threw for 1500 more yards, 12 more Tds, averaged 2 more yards per attempt (which tells us he threw the ball down the field much more often and better) and completed a much higher percentage of his passes while doing so....over the course of 12 games, not just one.
Click to expand...

He also rushed for 436 yards and 10 TDs. 4100 total yards and 37 total TDs....maybe the question to ask is if Kelly will be in the Heisman conversation
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
#214
#214
Whatever Dobbs accomplishes he does it with the most underperforming WR group in the league outside of Vandy. Malone drops one pass per game on average and the rest show up occasionally against the bottom half of the league and mid major opponents but not so much vs the top defenses in the langue.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
#215
#215
UT-Greg said:
Casey Clausen was twice the QB Dobbs is,I give it to Dobbs he can run but that's it he cant pass a lick he couldn"t hit the ocean standing on the beach In destin!
Click to expand...

Hitting the ocean from Destin would be a helluva throw.:)
 
#217
#217
jps2194 said:
But the downside is D4H will be rubbing it in everybody's face for months. And he will declare that he is in fact a genius and not just a genius in his own mind. :)
Click to expand...

I couldn't possibly care less about random internet guy stumbling into something being correct. If it means Dobbs leads this team to greatness, there is no downside.
 
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.
Advertisement



Back
Top