Casual Mustard Yeeter
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Sep 12, 2023
- Messages
- 202
- Likes
- 714
Nah usually the best team wins. Team and talent are not always the same thing.I’m feeling like UGA has 25 more 4-5 star players than UT. The talent advantage is still huge. Unless UGA has turnovers that UT turns into points . . . I don’t see a win.
It’s football . . . And anything can happen . . . But usually the team with the most talent wins.
I like our depth at every position better than UGA's. I think most people who assume UGA has this huge talent gap doesn't pay close attention to Georgia's roster outside of recruiting rankings which is no longer even a passable measure of the quality of a team's roster. ATLVol on 247 posted a couple of things I am going to share here. He keeps up with Georgia's roster.I’m feeling like UGA has 25 more 4-5 star players than UT. The talent advantage is still huge. Unless UGA has turnovers that UT turns into points . . . I don’t see a win.
It’s football . . . And anything can happen . . . But usually the team with the most talent wins.
All things equal - it’s the jimmies and the joes. I think both teams are well coached. I don’t agree with the narrative that CJH cannot beat Smart / Smart has him figured out / etc. Kirby has had and still has a significant talent advantage (in my opinion). Can a school have great talent and be a sub par team - yes. Why? They are poorly coached. I don’t think anyone could argue either team in this case is poorly coached. UGA has more talent - period. UT can win . . . But will need help in the areas of turnovers / special teams / etc (in my opinion).Nah usually the best team wins. Team and talent are not always the same thing.
Excellent points.I like our depth at every position better than UGA's. I think most people who assume UGA has this huge talent gap doesn't pay close attention to Georgia's roster outside of recruiting rankings which is no longer even a passable measure of the quality of a team's roster. ATLVol on 247 posted a couple of things I am going to share here. He keeps up with Georgia's roster.
"Love Brooks but couldn't disagree more about their OL. Stockton has been pressured a ton, and they don't have 1 surefire high NFL pick starting. They do, however, have a true freshman we all know (Juan Gaston) who beat out everyone else to start at OG in week 1 - however, he'll likely be out again this week with injury. They've got multiple True and RS Fr in their two-deep. Far from "stellar" IMO, and something that our Front 7 has to take advantage of, especially with Neyland behind them."
Kirby has complained publicly about his lack of depth.
"They're obviously very good, but what's also obvious is that they have not backfilled the insane amount of talent that's been lost over the last 2-3 NFL Draft cycles, not to mention (at least in terms of depth) to the portal. They just had a record 13 dudes drafted in June!
Just comparing this year to last year, Bolden is a stud at one S but last year they had him AND Starks. They've got solid Edge guys, but none of them approach the level of Walker and Williams - they do have Griffin and Gibson but right now they're both playing roles similar or less to what Dye and Campbell are playing. Their DL are obviously solid, but again nothing like they had in 21-23. DBs are highly rated but not gamebreakers so far.
ILBs on the other hand are very, very good with Allen/Cole/Williams/Wilson - easily the strongest unit on the entire team IMO.
Point being, yes, they are very talented and well coached for sure. But they are no longer the juggernaut NFL scout team on that side of the ball that we've faced since Heupel has been here. Finally, and to "yes, and" my own point, having been in Athens myself last season, the difference for our offense having to deal with that crowd + their piped in 80's hair metal music all the way up to every single snap vs. being in our own stadium is going to be huge for our offense."
"Based on who they're projecting to bring, IMO it's pretty obvious that while their ILB room is ferocious the rest of the defense just doesn't have the same level of talent or experience. For example, at OLB I think Johnson is talented but he doesn't look anything like the two first rounders from last season, and behind him is an Army transfer who hasn't broken through. At Star, Aguero is acknowledged as a weak link (that IMO we have to exploit with the Slot WR) and then JAGs, and CB has highly rated dudes who are fine but not projected first round picks like they've recently had. Same for S, where again Bolden is very good but Jones is a major question mark that they brought in 3(!!!) transfers to try and win the job over but haven't.
Let me reiterate: They're good. They're talented. BUT I just don't see them as anywhere near what they've had in the last seasons where they've been truly elite and overflowing with 1st/2nd day NFL picks for the upcoming draft."
Could you at least act like you were raised in the South and learned what hospitality is? You're embarrassing, to be honest.
All things are rarely equal though.All things equal - it’s the jimmies and the joes. I think both teams are well coached. I don’t agree with the narrative that CJH cannot beat Smart / Smart has him figured out / etc. Kirby has had and still has a significant talent advantage (in my opinion). Can a school have great talent and be a sub par team - yes. Why? They are poorly coached. I don’t think anyone could argue either team in this case is poorly coached. UGA has more talent - period. UT can win . . . But will need help in the areas of turnovers / special teams / etc (in my opinion).
I like our depth at every position better than UGA's. I think most people who assume UGA has this huge talent gap doesn't pay close attention to Georgia's roster outside of recruiting rankings which is no longer even a passable measure of the quality of a team's roster. ATLVol on 247 posted a couple of things I am going to share here. He keeps up with Georgia's roster.
"Love Brooks but couldn't disagree more about their OL. Stockton has been pressured a ton, and they don't have 1 surefire high NFL pick starting. They do, however, have a true freshman we all know (Juan Gaston) who beat out everyone else to start at OG in week 1 - however, he'll likely be out again this week with injury. They've got multiple True and RS Fr in their two-deep. Far from "stellar" IMO, and something that our Front 7 has to take advantage of, especially with Neyland behind them."
Kirby has complained publicly about his lack of depth.
"They're obviously very good, but what's also obvious is that they have not backfilled the insane amount of talent that's been lost over the last 2-3 NFL Draft cycles, not to mention (at least in terms of depth) to the portal. They just had a record 13 dudes drafted in June!
Just comparing this year to last year, Bolden is a stud at one S but last year they had him AND Starks. They've got solid Edge guys, but none of them approach the level of Walker and Williams - they do have Griffin and Gibson but right now they're both playing roles similar or less to what Dye and Campbell are playing. Their DL are obviously solid, but again nothing like they had in 21-23. DBs are highly rated but not gamebreakers so far.
ILBs on the other hand are very, very good with Allen/Cole/Williams/Wilson - easily the strongest unit on the entire team IMO.
Point being, yes, they are very talented and well coached for sure. But they are no longer the juggernaut NFL scout team on that side of the ball that we've faced since Heupel has been here. Finally, and to "yes, and" my own point, having been in Athens myself last season, the difference for our offense having to deal with that crowd + their piped in 80's hair metal music all the way up to every single snap vs. being in our own stadium is going to be huge for our offense."
"Based on who they're projecting to bring, IMO it's pretty obvious that while their ILB room is ferocious the rest of the defense just doesn't have the same level of talent or experience. For example, at OLB I think Johnson is talented but he doesn't look anything like the two first rounders from last season, and behind him is an Army transfer who hasn't broken through. At Star, Aguero is acknowledged as a weak link (that IMO we have to exploit with the Slot WR) and then JAGs, and CB has highly rated dudes who are fine but not projected first round picks like they've recently had. Same for S, where again Bolden is very good but Jones is a major question mark that they brought in 3(!!!) transfers to try and win the job over but haven't.
Let me reiterate: They're good. They're talented. BUT I just don't see them as anywhere near what they've had in the last seasons where they've been truly elite and overflowing with 1st/2nd day NFL picks for the upcoming draft."