Jay Cutler is from Santa Claus, IN and went to high school in Lincoln City, a small town in southern Indiana. Knowing where Nashville is, a large capital city which is 2.5 hours and 160 miles away from where he was born and had lived his entire life up until that point, would hardly have made him a geography buff. If he was from the west coast or something, I suppose I could understand not knowing where it was, even though Nashville is a decent-sized city and the capital of a state. It isn't some backwater town.
That's mind-blowing he didn't know where Nashville was, or seemingly had never heard of it. Especially considering he was strong enough academically to get into Vandy. That's like a kid who was born and lived in Dalton, GA not knowing where Nashville is.