I said this in another thread but it belongs here.
I'll take Collinsworth over anybody not named Romo. Collinsworth breaks down X's and O's pretty well. Simms is captain obvious. So is Aikman. Moose called triple coverage "cover 3" this year.
It's been 4 years and I have changed my mind about Aikman and Collinsworth. Although I think Collinsworth is really good with the technical aspects of breaking down X's and O's, the personality isn't great and it's getting really old. Although I think Aikman sucks with the X's and O's, I love that he will let you know when a QB sucks. He won't hold back and nobody else does that, so I appreciate it. Also, I still want Romo more than anybody, but if it's not a good game, Romo sucks. His strength is on-the-fly commentary, and nobody is on his level. If the game is bad, then you have to turn to what you prepared to discuss when it went that way, and he just doesn't know what he's doing in that regard.
Also, I miss nerd. He was a good dude.