I don't agree with the personnel misuse. Butch doesn't pick the starters in a dark room by himself, these are staff decisions. Perhaps with one exception.
The coaches have to consider down side issues with the upside. Fans get to live on the upside alone.
Just because a player does well when he gets an opportunity doesn't mean he was the best at that position all along. You have to remember the younger guys improve at a faster rate then the older guys.
I don't believe Dobbs was the best QB in game 1 that season. By the time he got his opportunity, yes. Kamara was not better than Hurd in his first year here. The same could be said about others.
No doubt there was somebody calling for CFA to get some playing time before the SC game. Oops down side. And one day soon we'll be talking about how great CFA is and how under utilized he was.
If your not watching practice, you have no way to know the players down side issues.