Carl Pickens
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Nov 6, 2006
- Messages
- 46,389
- Likes
- 64,781
Astounds me the University known for Peyton Manning cannot recruit a top tier QB.JG was throwing to the receiver crossing the back of the end zone and the ball would have been 5 yards behind him had it not gotten deflected
The current JR and Sr classes are major disappointments outside of a few solid players. I think Pruitt should go with the youth movement at this point. The players don’t know their responsibilities or how to line up correctly anyway.Astounds me the University known for Peyton Manning cannot recruit a top tier QB.
I'm gonna quit the discussion of FGs, though. Even a win last night doesn't change the path we are on this year as a team and for the future as a program.
Instead of UT.The current JR and Sr classes are major disappointments outside of a few solid players. I think Pruitt should go with the youth movement at this point. The players don’t know their responsibilities or how to line up correctly anyway.
I bet some position coaches got an earful after the game last night.
The current JR and Sr classes are major disappointments outside of a few solid players. I think Pruitt should go with the youth movement at this point. The players don’t know their responsibilities or how to line up correctly anyway.
I bet some position coaches got an earful after the game last night.
I’m not sure thatFulmer has anything to do with it. Besides that, even if he did, do you realize how high scoring our offense was under him. The Heath Shuler/Peyton Manning years were very high scoring.What happened with Chaney? He was wide open under Dooley. When I see the conservatism with the offense I am concerned that Pruitt and Fulmer have a hand in it.
To repeat: we don’t know what we have at QB with JT and BM bc there was NEVER a legit QB competition in the first place! JG was anointed as our starter based on experience alone. His ego is too fragile to withstand a legit competition. That much should be clear by now.,He knows..... but he also sees the other QBs at practice everyday.... the cupboard must be bare
You can’t actually believe Fulmer is in anyway involved with play calling or game day scheming. That’s beyond ridiculous. If asked I am sure he provides input. I am sure he is never asked.What happened with Chaney? He was wide open under Dooley. When I see the conservatism with the offense I am concerned that Pruitt and Fulmer have a hand in it.
It would have been a half the distance penalty. Not a full 5 yards.Mcdad you are one of my favorite people on VN...you know this. I couldnt disagree more with you though.
I do not EVER EVER want a coach who doesnt believe in his team enough to go for it. Both times we failed.. on 4th and 1. You go for 4th and 1 every single time. If we cant do that, shouldnt wear orange.
I hate that Pruitt didnt take the 5yd offsides penalty INSTEAD of the made FG that would have given us 4th and half a yard at the 1. We should have taken that for a TD. This is football. 18 inches with 11 guys. We cant get that then we dont need to even put on pads and pretend to be a football team
Mcdad you are one of my favorite people on VN...you know this. I couldnt disagree more with you though.
I do not EVER EVER want a coach who doesnt believe in his team enough to go for it. Both times we failed.. on 4th and 1. You go for 4th and 1 every single time. If we cant do that, shouldnt wear orange.
I hate that Pruitt didnt take the 5yd offsides penalty INSTEAD of the made FG that would have given us 4th and half a yard at the 1. We should have taken that for a TD. This is football. 18 inches with 11 guys. We cant get that then we dont need to even put on pads and pretend to be a football team
yup then start a TF on road at Florida. Makes sense.
Astounds me the University known for Peyton Manning cannot recruit a top tier QB.
I'm gonna quit the discussion of FGs, though. Even a win last night doesn't change the path we are on this year as a team and for the future as a program.
You forget the Dooley years too quickly, he has called some terribly predictable games in his time here (and Georgia). I think his over-all scheme can win, I think his play calling is suspect.What happened with Chaney? He was wide open under Dooley. When I see the conservatism with the offense I am concerned that Pruitt and Fulmer have a hand in it.
Yea both touchdowns were terrible passes, JJ is a hero we dont deserve. There were very few "good" passes all night, completions that could have gone for big gains were snatched out of the dirt, toe down out of bounds, deflections ect.JG was throwing to the receiver crossing the back of the end zone and the ball would have been 5 yards behind him had it not gotten deflected
I agree. We kick, we win. It is hard to leave points on the field. We are in no position to leave points on the field. TDs are preferred but getting points out of a drive is the goal. Points are points. If all we did was kick field goals for the rest of the year and we won I don’t think the majority would complain. Plenty on here would for sureBut it isnt moot. The are common reasons going for it on 4th (when not critical for victory). One is to give your offense line confidence. It can be a big boost to the psyches of young men to know thecoach believes in them. We had rushed well and pass protected well. The confidence should be in how they played during the entire game.
The other reason is to give your defense some additional rest. This would be the only reason I can fathom doing it during the BYU game.
You harken back to GSU but that isn't valid for last nights game. We had a history in the game we were playing. We were playing good defense (until fatigued). And Cimaglia was on the money. There is no reason to not kick.
So why did we go for it? Bad coaching decisions. Those 3 - 6 points means no overtime.