You are correct. We/the press don't need to know why a specific player was or was not disciplined. What the fan base would like to know, before the AD commits to a multi year multi million dollar extension for Josh, is that he truly can react to adversity in what ever form it comes. Player talent, player dissention, coaching schemes, coaching talent, NIL issues awareness, multiple player injuries. Fortunately for Vol fans, we have a near term opportunity for immediate evaluation, Vandy. Another performance like South Carolina, anything less than an ass kicking , we move from pay the man to wait and see. One man's opinion.