Bailey>Manning

Bailey or Manning?

  • HB

    Votes: 38 8.9%

  • PM

    Votes: 391 91.1%
  • Total voters
    429
#79
#79
Ummm...my take is probably not given how cerebral Peyton was. But I think that Manhattan clam chowder>New England clam chowder on account the former uses healthier ingredients than the later. So more likely than not the brainy Peyton would make a better food choice than teen-infected Harrison. Just Manning up, folks.
 
Last edited:
#86
#86
BigOrangeTrain said:
To the people who voted for HB, how about making yourself known? I would love to hear some reasonings for your answer.
Click to expand...

I haven't bet, but HB would be an intriguing bet. Manning didn't accomplish much at Tennessee. You give me a player with 4-5 years upcoming, and all he has to do is to win two SECe in that time (and one SECc) then I'd be pretty tempted.
 
#88
#88
CrybabyVol said:
I haven't bet, but HB would be an intriguing bet. Manning didn't accomplish much at Tennessee. You give me a player with 4-5 years upcoming, and all he has to do is to win two SECe in that time (and one SECc) then I'd be pretty tempted.
Click to expand...
Manning helped Tennessee win an SEC Championship so you can't say he accomplished much:rolleyes:
 
#89
#89
Tennesseefan2019 said:
Manning helped Tennessee win an SEC Championship so you can't say he accomplished much:rolleyes:
Click to expand...

Rex Grossman won an SEC championship at Florida. Same resume except Grossman didn't lose to Memphis. Peyton did not not accomplish much here. Heck. Chris Leak at UF won a national championship and an SEC championship. If you traded players right now, would you have a street named after Grossman? Leak? UF doesn't. Cam Newton achieved unthinkable things at Auburn. McCelroy has a natty at AL. We need to foster Martin and Price more than Manning. The Manning adulation is embarrassing to our school.
 
#90
#90
CrybabyVol said:
Peyton is a VFL, and his contributions are noted. However, he's not the appropriate measuring stick. He didn't accomplish much while at Tennessee. On the other hand, in the NFL ... Many Vol posters cannot separate the two. Many national talking heads cannot separate the two. I've never witnessed something quite like Peyton. There is a segment of our fan base that get emotional about him. I don't see this with Auburn and Bo Jackson. I don't see this with Alabama and Mark Ingram. I don't see this with Florida and Danny Wuerrfel. I also firmly believe that putting the team's shortcomings square on Peyton's shoulders is unfair. QBs get way too much credit and way too much blame. But I'll say this. If Peyton would have taken his exact college results to UGA/UF/AL he would not have streets, locker rooms, etc. named after him.
Click to expand...
Jesus give it up....we don't care what you see with Florida and Auburn....you are ridiculous to think if Peyton had went to Florida or Georgia he wouldn't have been one of the greatest QB of all time there too...He is by far the best QB Tennessee has ever had and had a great college career no matter how much you want to diminish it
 
  • Like
Reactions: MemphisVol77 and Behr
#91
#91
CrybabyVol said:
Rex Grossman won an SEC championship at Florida. Same resume except Grossman didn't lose to Memphis. Peyton did not not accomplish much here. Heck. Chris Leak at UF won a national championship and an SEC championship. If you traded players right now, would you have a street named after Grossman? Leak? UF doesn't. Cam Newton achieved unthinkable things at Auburn. McCelroy has a natty at AL. We need to foster Martin and Price more than Manning. The Manning adulation is embarrassing to our school.
Click to expand...
good thing your opinion is just yours, because you're wrong...I love all elite UT players from Manning to White to Berry to Suffridge...Peyton will be loved throughout history as a VFL much like the other legends here...just because you don't like him doesnt mean anything...39-6 as a starter with 1 SEC title, 1 NC game appearance and is considered one of the greatest college AND NFL QB of all time...and you....are basically you lol
 
  • Like
Reactions: lifeisdeep
#93
#93
WoodsmanVol said:
Ummm...my take is probably not given how cerebral Peyton was. But I think that Manhattan clam chowder>New England clam chowder on account the former uses healthier ingredients than the later. So more likely than not the brainy Peyton would make a better food choice than teen-infected Harrison. Just manning up, folks.
Click to expand...

It requires esoteric knowledge to understand your wisdom sir.
 
#94
#94
Rickyvol77 said:
good thing your opinion is just yours, because you're wrong...I love all elite UT players from Manning to White to Berry to Suffridge...Peyton will be loved throughout history as a VFL much like the other legends here...just because you don't like him doesnt mean anything...39-6 as a starter with 1 SEC title, 1 NC game appearance and is considered one of the greatest college AND NFL QB of all time...and you....are basically you lol
Click to expand...

I either had a post removed or it just didn't connect through. Peyton did not have a NC appearance. Please stop saying that.
 
#95
#95
BigOrangeTrain said:
Jesus why do some Vol fans do this? The kid hasnt even thrown a pass in college and he is already being mentioned in the same breath as the best QB in school history? Good grief. How about let Bailey carve out his own legacy and NOT compare him to any former QB?
Click to expand...
People “do this” because it gets people like you all riled up, and that’s amusing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Big Al Orange and Behr
#98
#98
VolforFootball said:
Do you think Bailey will be better than Manning?
Click to expand...
HB has he physical talent to be as good as any QB who has played at Tennessee. To date, PM had the best mental and work-ethic of any QB who has played at Tennessee. PM also had exceptional talent surrounding him. We do not yet know how HB applies his mental and work-ethic or a comparison of the talent level he will be play with at Tennessee. Therefore, I don't think I can "guess" how HB's carrier will progress, but I do think he is the best QB talent we have signed at Tennessee since PM. If HB becomes the student of the game as strongly as PM did, he has a chance to become as good as PM at Tennessee. We will see what happens in the next 3-5 years. The ride should be a lot of fun.
 
#99
#99
CrybabyVol said:
I either had a post removed or it just didn't connect through. Peyton did not have a NC appearance. Please stop saying that.
Click to expand...
yes he did as you have been proven wrong several times...the Orange Bowl was the Bowl Alliance NC game...just because you want to minimize it, doesn't mean it's not factual
 
#100
#100
OG.V83 said:
It requires esoteric knowledge to understand your wisdom sir.
Click to expand...

Yes, but you see in a thread such as the OP started, one full of foolery and folly; one must try to insert some Arcade jolly.

250px-Arcade_%28supervillain%29.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: OG.V83
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.
Advertisement



Back
Top