Just step back and thing about it. Putting fandom aside, if you were hand-picking a roster...
1. Would you rather have Rohan Davey & Matt Mauck (both would be all-SEC) or Casey Clausen?
2. Would you rather have Domanick Williams & Toefield or Travis Stephens?
3. Would you rather have Josh Reed, Michael Clayton, Devery Henderson, Robert Royal, Eric Edwards, Domanick Williams and Toefield to catch passes or Stallworth, Washington, Witten, Parker, Graham, Stephens and Bartholomew?
The first two would be easily LSU; the third would be closer, but still favor LSU. Collectively, it's an easy choice in favor of LSU.
In 2001, Casey Clausen and Stephens.
In 2001, I also Would've taken our WR corps considering Royal, Henderson (who wasn't an SEC WR at the time, instead a RB), Williams (didn't record a catch), and Edwards (had two catches) didn't do much at all. Reed and Clayton vs. Stallworth, Washington, Witten, Parker, etc...
Are you even serious?