Some bad replies to you 99 but it's because of your apples and oranges comparison.
IMO roster management is > recruit rankings. If that wasn't true no way do you get clocks cleaned by Bama in 09 and have the season you did in 10. You had talent, truckloads of it. You did not have the right talent or the talent you did have in a great position to win. UT has to excel what FL sucked at last year, making more with less. It's DD's recipe and we see this year and next if he can do it well enough.
Waco in my readings gets this better than you ever have.
Posted via VolNation Mobile
oh, i agree. talent isn't everything.
there's the famous line about bear bryant that he could beat you with his or yours.
you have to coach them and develop them, etc, etc.
i say all the time, 1/3 of almost every recruiting class does nothing. flunk out, kicked out, transfer,injury, etc.
it's just the more highly rated the players, the more likely that the ones who pan out, pan out at a high level.
the other thing that's true is an exceptional player or two can lift the level of play of everyone around them which is what makes auburn's season in 2010 so remarkable. cam newton and nick fairly made two very average units good enough to go win a national title.
i just believe in the rule and not the exception to the rule.
it's very hard to go out and win big if you are being out-recruited within the league.
so, to use mississippi state as an example. they beat florida and georgia in 2010. two teams with much more talent. but, they still lost 4 football games. so, they overachieved (based on talent) and still lost four games. that's good at mississippi state, but that won't fly at tennessee.