Israel vs Palestinians II

#3,226
#3,226
85SugarVol said:
10%? That’s 220,000. Not even Huff’s histrionic ass claims anything remotely that high.

But sure - let’s play this one out as well…

Bama - They haven’t taken out the population
Tuck - They’re well on their way

[Checks notes, 90% of Gazan population remains]

Do you remember any of your 2nd grade math?
Click to expand...
Bro I was being a smart ass I thought that was pretty obvious. But yes killing 10% of a population does qualify as a genocide. And I never claimed 10% the ex IDF chief did.

Do you think the entire population has to die for it to be a genocide? I guess I skipped 2nd grade, while you never went past it.
 
#3,227
#3,227
Ttucke11 said:
Bro I was being a smart ass I thought that was pretty obvious. But yes killing 10% of a population does qualify as a genocide. And I never claimed 10% the ex IDF chief did.

Do you think the entire population has to die for it to be a genocide? I guess I skipped 2nd grade, while you never went past it.
Click to expand...

Sometimes it’s called a good start.
 
#3,228
#3,228
Ttucke11 said:
Bro I was being a smart ass I thought that was pretty obvious. But yes killing 10% of a population does qualify as a genocide. And I never claimed 10% the ex IDF chief did.

Do you think the entire population has to die for it to be a genocide? I guess I skipped 2nd grade, while you never went past it.
Click to expand...
Let’s go back to the beginning, as you are obviously either spun, or scrambling.

Bama said the population hasn’t been “wiped out”
bamawriter said:
If Israel had no purpose other than to wipe out the population of Gaza, the population of Gaza would already be wiped out.
Click to expand...
You said they were “well on their way”
Ttucke11 said:
Well on their way it seems.
Click to expand...

It was pointed out 3% (6% on the actual high side) of the population has been lost.

Now you’ve pivoted to talking about Genocide, which was never part of the moronic statement that reads -

“Israel is well on its way to wiping out the Gazan population”

But I completely understand you desperately trying to run from it.
 
#3,229
#3,229
85SugarVol said:
Let’s go back to the beginning, as you are obviously either spun, or scrambling.

Bama said the population hasn’t been “wiped out”

You said they were “well on their way”


It was pointed out 3% (6% on the actual high side) of the population has been lost.

Now you’ve pivoted to talking about Genocide, which was never part of the moronic statement that reads -

“Israel is well on its way to wiping out the Gazan population”

But I completely understand you desperately trying to run from it.
Click to expand...

I made an off hand one comment in a million posts being a smart ass saying "well on their way". If this is your gotcha moment, ya got me.

I didn't pivot to anything. Just trying to help educate you on what a genocide is. Not running from anything at all.

But I guess 6% of a population gone in 2 years isn't a big deal or a start.

You can keep being an apologist for child slaughter all you want.
 
#3,232
#3,232
Ttucke11 said:
I made an off hand one comment in a million posts being a smart ass saying "well on their way". If this is your gotcha moment, ya got me.

I didn't pivot to anything. Just trying to help educate you on what a genocide is. Not running from anything at all.

But I guess 6% of a population gone in 2 years isn't a big deal or a start.

You can keep being an apologist for child slaughter all you want.
Click to expand...
I know well the UN definition of genocide that you cling to.

You were running from Israel is “well on its way” to “wiping out” the Gazan population.
Which again, is totally understandable, and why you have now abandoned it - bravo.

If you had chosen to say 3% (the actual number) “is a start”, that would have at least been reasonable. Alas, you did not.

And color me completely shocked that a veritable Titan of Logic (such as yourself) would conclude with such a fantastically absurd Strawman. Well done.
 
  • Like
Reactions: MemphisVol77 and InVOLuntary
#3,233
#3,233
85SugarVol said:
I know well the UN definition of genocide that you cling to.

You were running from Israel is “well on its way” to “wiping out” the Gazan population.
Which again, is totally understandable, and why you have now abandoned it - bravo.

If you had chosen to say 3% (the actual number) “is a start”, that would have at least been reasonable. Alas, you did not.

And color me completely shocked that a veritable Titan of Logic (such as yourself) would conclude with such a fantastically absurd Strawman. Well done.
Click to expand...
Please quote me on "wiping out" the Gazan population. I'll help, I didn't say that. So false argument. I didn't give any number besides 20K kids. I stated what other people said aka the IDF chief. Another false argument by you.

And quite honestly I don't even know what the **** point youre trying to even make or argue with me about. Lol. Israel is justified. The slaughter of innocent children is worth it!!!! You happy now?

PS I actually have no idea what the UN specifically uses as it's basis for genocide I'm just using common knowledge.

Good to know that sugarvol has the exact number of deaths though when the rest of the world is quite torn. Congrats on your omniscient abilities sir.
 
Last edited:
#3,235
#3,235
Ttucke11 said:
Once again I agree Hamas is evil, they do evil things. When you point your gun at someone you are taught to "point at your target, know what's in front, and what's beyond it". You are responsible for that bullet. If you think the collateral damage is justified, I understand. I do not. I expect the 2nd most well funded military In the world to be a little more tactful.

Second, sure I know they could. It's a modern day top of the line army vs leftover Soviet weapons and untrained men. I'd say the outcry from the rest of the world has prevented the complete destruction of the region more than the restraint of the Israeli government.
Click to expand...
The Gulf states leadership were largely "eh" until the Qatar strikes. The people didn't support it however.
 
#3,237
#3,237
Ttucke11 said:
IDF chief estimated 10%. UN declared it genocide. Take it up with them.
Click to expand...
The UN is a useless affinity group. Their findings, statements and condemnations are as credible as Morgan Wallen is with hip hop fans and Beyonce with country fans

Don't get me started on that useless money pit.

And before you ask my opinion of them isn't based on anything to do with Israel, only supported by it.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: InVOLuntary
#3,238
#3,238
KB5252 said:
The UN is a useless affinity group. Their findings, v statements and condensations are as credible as Morgan Wallen is with hip hop fans and Beyonce with country fans

Don't get me started on that useless money pit.

And before you ask my opinion of them isn't based on anything to do with Israel, only supported by it.
Click to expand...
I don't care for the UN at all. But no "good" sources exist. Everyone would criticize any source I used one way or the other.
 
#3,239
#3,239
Ttucke11 said:
I made an off hand one comment in a million posts being a smart ass saying "well on their way". If this is your gotcha moment, ya got me.

I didn't pivot to anything. Just trying to help educate you on what a genocide is. Not running from anything at all.

But I guess 6% of a population gone in 2 years isn't a big deal or a start.

You can keep being an apologist for child slaughter all you want.
Click to expand...
6% is a a large number and tragic. But put it in context. 141 square miles, the equivalent of 12+ Hiroshima weapons in yield. Yet only 6% of the population? Israel is either completely inept at killing as many Palestinians as possible or that was never the intention. Only one of those two options is possible to an intellectually honesty mind.

It's tragic sure, but Israel has done what it could to minimize civilians while inflicting as much death and destruction on Hamas it possibly could.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MemphisVol77 and hog88
#3,240
#3,240
Ttucke11 said:
Please quote me on "wiping out" the Gazan population. I'll help, I didn't say that. So false argument. I didn't give any number besides 20K kids. I stated what other people said aka the IDF chief. Another false argument by you.

And quite honestly I don't even know what the **** point youre trying to even make or argue with me about. Lol. Israel is justified. The slaughter of innocent children is worth it!!!! You happy now?

PS I actually have no idea what the UN specifically uses as it's basis for genocide I'm just using common knowledge.

Good to know that sugarvol has the exact number of deaths though when the rest of the world is quite torn. Congrats on your omniscient abilities sir.
Click to expand...
Wow. Do we really have to back to the beginning? Again?

Bama - Gaza population hasn’t been “wiped out”
You - “Well on their way”

Those are your words. Your response.

What exactly were they “well on their way” to? You know, other than the post you were responding to?
 
#3,241
#3,241
KB5252 said:
6% is a a large number and tragic. But keys out it in context. 141 square miles, the equivalent of 12+ Hiroshima weapons in yield. Yet only 6% of the population? Israel is either completely inept as killing as many Palestinians as possible or that was never the intention. Only one of those two options is possible to an intellectual honesty mind.

It's tragic sure, but Israel has done what it could to minimize civilians while inflicting as much death and destruction on Hamas is possibly could.
Click to expand...
I respect your opinion and the way you delivered it. I think the Israeli government is about as sweet and benevolent as our own though. Take that how you will.
 
#3,242
#3,242
85SugarVol said:
Wow. Do we really have to back to the beginning? Again?

Bama - Gaza population hasn’t been “wiped out”
You - “Well on their way”

Those are your words. Your response.

What exactly were they “well on their way” to? You know, other than the post you were responding to?
Click to expand...
Dude you are so hung up on my shortest post In this thread that I already stated was an off hand comment being a smartass. I was making a dark joke about well on their way to genocide bc of how flippant everyone was to 3, 6, or 10% of a population being wiped out. Give it a rest.

I'm very sorry I criticized Israel. They're justified in anything. Don't worry.
 
#3,245
#3,245
Ttucke11 said:
I respect your opinion and the way you delivered it. I think the Israeli government is about as sweet and benevolent as our own though. Take that how you will.
Click to expand...
I'm not calling them benevolent, and your comparison is absolutely valid.

They, much like we approach every sorti with a ratio. In air strikes we are willing to take out x number of collateral for every target. As they say war is hell.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ttucke11
#3,247
#3,247
Ttucke11 said:
Dude you are so hung up on my shortest post In this thread that I already stated was an off hand comment being a smartass. I was making a dark joke about well on their way to genocide bc of how flippant everyone was to 3, 6, or 10% of a population being wiped out. Give it a rest.

I'm very sorry I criticized Israel. They're justified in anything. Don't worry.
Click to expand...
Well now that you’ve abandoned that one and we can put it to bed, maybe we can work on these ghastly strawmen you keep putting forth.
 
#3,248
#3,248
85SugarVol said:
Well now that you’ve abandoned that one and we can put it to bed, maybe we can work on these ghastly strawmen you keep putting forth.
Click to expand...
Ok bro lmao. Still don't know what the **** you were trying to prove or argue with me about but congrats on yelling at the wall. I only had to say the same thing to you 3 times in a row. Team Israel!

But please do pick apart a strawman now that the broken record is fixed.
 
#3,250
#3,250
Ttucke11 said:
Ok bro lmao. Still don't know what the **** you were trying to prove or argue with me about but congrats on yelling at the wall. I only had to say the same thing to you 3 times in a row. Team Israel!

But please do pick apart a strawman now that the broken record is fixed.
Click to expand...
Man, the wall sure does double and triple down, a lot. Until its position becomes completely and utterly untenable. So I guess there’s hope for it 🤷‍♀️
 
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.
Advertisement

Back
Top