I’m in the same boat as everyone else regarding who our starting QB will be. That’s not my call, thankfully. My best guess is that JG is the starter and KC is his backup. As someone earlier alluded to, I take much of the reporting from fall camp with a grain of salt but what was reported on day one from Rutherford in particular was not at all surprising.
From Rutherford on day one
“I can tell Jarrett Guarantano has been working on his timing and his touch on deep passes. He lofted a beautiful rainbow of a pass down the sidelines about 30 yards or so, and it hit the intended target in stride. He also looks to be in better rhythm than he was during the season last year, but like I said, this was without any pass rushers coming at him or defensive backs guarding the receivers
For Keller Chryst, I saw a quarterback who looks poised in the pocket and definitely seems like he has more experience than anyone else on UT’s roster. I’ve never been impressed with his throwing motion, and it didn’t seem like had as much zip on the ball as Guarantano did today. But his throwing motion was good enough for him to throw 19 touchdowns compared to just six interceptions at Stanford and helped him go 11-2 as a starter, so he makes it work for him.”
This was the report on KC at the Elite 11 finals in 2013.
Count Elite 11 head coach Trent Dilfer among those impressed with the 6'4, 220-pounders skill set and not for the reasons most expect.
It's funny, I don't get enamored by his arm at all," Dilfer said on Saturday evening during a media availability. "I get enamored with his ability to tempo the ball. We were working on a drill that had the tight end coming right in front of the quarterback on a crossing route and Keller just understands throwing a catchable ball. He has a natural ability to tempo and it's a ball that finishes really smooth. I think he gets it just with his release, his snap," Dilfer said. "At times he gets a little bit long, which we've worked on, but he has a really natural snap of his wrist, the way the ball comes off of his fingers and he finishes with his wrist. I think that's why he's able to do it and why he's able to conceptualize it."
This was the report on JG at the Elite 11 finals in 2015.
How good is Guarantano? "He's almost too talented," Dilfer said. Essentially, Guarantano can make every throw in the book — and do so with unmatched speed and power – but needs to spend more time working on his touch. "Layering," basically, meaning the ability to put balls over the tops of defenders rather than relying on pure arm strength to defeat coverage. It's not a huge issue to have at this stage in his development. "He's got everything you could ever want," said Dilfer. I would bet on Guarantano eventually being named MVP of this event. Tennessee is getting a superb prospect.”
From Simonton on day one
“Quick takeaways from what I could see: Jarrett Guarantano took the first rep and threw a perfect ball to Josh Palmer … and it was dropped. The rest of the period was much cleaner, though. I didn’t think Keller Chryst had a ton of zip on his balls, but again, it’s hard to really gauge based on the viewpoints for the media.”
From Patrick Brown on day one
“Keller Chryst is listed at 6-5/239 and that's not off. He's a big cat. Carries himself like he's been here for longer than a couple of months.
Chryst and Jarrett Guarantano were each sharp on the short routes and had at least one overthrow on intermediate-to-deep routes. Freshman JT Shrout also had some sharp throws but was more up and down with his accuracy. The Vols overall probably had more balls hit the ground than they would have liked even for a first day.
The period ended with Guarantano, Will McBride and Shrout rolling out and throwing deep passes down the sideline to slot receivers Brandon Johnson, Latrell Williams and Jacquez Jones. The freshman had the best throw of the three. Johnson had to stop to catch Guarantano's pass, Williams had no chance of catching McBride's overthrown ball and Jones only had to pull up a little bit to catch the pass from Shrout.”
My reasons at his point for guessing JG wins the job is 1) he’s not a freshman any more so I’m expecting a significant jump in his ability to adjust to the speed of an SEC game. 2) He has Helton and Weinke to tutor him.
I think we have two different QBs with two different "styles" and while KC is competing for the job I think we probably also needed a better backup option than what appeared to be available behind JG. Jmo.