I'm a fan, I like the fact that there's unlimited courses, and that the gameplay is gimmick free, no boosts/ratings etc, you just go out and play golf. Graphically it's pretty, nothing like the EA golf game will be, but that one will probably ship with max a dozen courses and charge for more.
The replayability is what makes it great, they've supposedly really improved the turn based multiplayer to where it goes relatively smoothly, though I haven't checked it out yet to be honest.