Welcome to the thread and thanks for the change in tone, derision to discussion. You don't have to agree with the hire; however, no discussion can occur if it devolves into a sarcasm contest.
Speaking from experience (not equating anything I have done in any way, shape, or form mind you), a young coach can do some head-scratching things. I will never forget one idiotic coaching decision I made all those years ago. I look back on some decisions I made 22 years ago, and I want to kick my on rear. What I thought was the right thing to do, experience, observation, and study have shown me otherwise. Good coaches grow and learn from their experiences.
Gruden was a very young coach. I don't think that he made terrible decisions personally, but each to their own on that. I don't think pro coach Gruden would have even considered a college job. Since TB, he has had the chance to run camps, consult with athletes, offer critiques and advice, and even coach his son's high school team. With these more recent experiences, it seems to me that he has come to a realization: he likes teaching football to young athletes. That's what we are missing at UT. We need a coach that will earn the players' respect and has the ability to TEACH these players. I think Gruden's recent experiences show that he is a very capable teacher of the game and not just bright football mind. I see his passion in working with young players and seeing them grow. That's what we need in Knoxville, a passionate teacher of the game. I don't think Dooley is an Xs and Os idiot. I do think that he is a terrible teacher of the game. I don't care if you're the smartest football guy in history. If you can't transfer that knowledge effectively to your players, all that knowledge is useless. Players don't automatically give their unconditional respect to a coach. That must be earned. Without rehashing a debate that has occured so many times, I see nothing that tells me that Dooley has earned his players' unconditional respect. Gruden, imo, brings passion for the game. His accomplishments will automatically earn respect. But most of all, his newly found love of teaching the game (which occurred outside the limelight) is exactly what we need at the University of Tennessee.
Again, welcome to the thread. I look forward to a meaningful discussion.:hi: