I think the AD should meet with the ncaa again and declare that there will be no scholarship reduction. Unless they actually punish michigan.
Then inform them that it could be very publicly embarrassing for them if the comparison was made very publicly.
Then walk out without waiting for an answer.
The NCAA also needs to be called out on Michigan's
three additional major violations that the NCAA corruptly excluded from its announced decision.
(1) Illegal use of university computers in the football complex (which was serious enough to involve the FBI, but has been completely hushed up without explanation by the NCAA, Michigan, and the press). (2) Illegally stealing signals from their regular season opponents (over two years, iirc). (3) illegally stealing signals from teams they thought might be playoff opponents, which Michigan further did not prevent from being obtained an opponent of one of those teams.* That action by Michigan literally corrupted the composition and integrity of the playoffs causing irreparable damage to the teams affected and to the reputation of the sport.
It's painfully obvious that the NCAA corruptly stalled on the first two of these five violations (only acting this week), intentionally aiding and abetting Michigan's illicit playoff participation. And the NCAA postponed treating the latter 3 still-unpunished charges because the five together would appear to most everyone as lack of institutional control. (Consider also that the Michigan's university leadership, not only the football team, was involved in covering up the university computer use scandal.)
The result now is not only that those at Michigan most responsible for all five violations were enabled by the NCAA's corrupt stalling to flee safely and profitably to the NFL (as everyone in the world predicted based on the NCAA's well known practice of crookedly playing favorites). But Michigan is now on three-year probation (if with no scholarship reductions or other penalties). And this with three
long-documented and well known allegations outstanding. The NCAA processing those three violations would result in three major probation violations ASAP.
Thus it reasonable to guess that the crooked NCAA in a private deal with its pet Michigan has promised under the table to exempt Michigan's three huge outstanding violations from the NCAA's own rules regarding probation. Not surprisingly, not a single "journalist" has wondered out loud about this, much less investigated it.
* (The ticket receipts at Neyland in the name of Michigan's operative and in Michigan's usual location with the best view of the signaling was reported during last season.) The wristbands were widely disseminated
on the internet at that time.
Sorry for the long response.