How many of those TF 5*'s hadn't played an entire year prior to going to the SEC and started year 1? How many of them came in overweight and out of shape as bad as KMac? That explains the hold up last year for CJJ (not Butch) starting experience over out of shape and rusty talent IMO.
As for this season, not that it really matters who starts cause this will be a Dline by committee, you have a veteran player in Danny O that has been the most improved player on D according to mult players/coaches and KMac that will have to prove to the staff he can be a 3 down lineman and stay disruptive throughout several series before they give him the nod. I'm fine with the "prove it" mentality.
Let's see who gets the lion share of snaps during the 4 game stretch and that will tell who Shoop (not Butch) thinks is the best.