The hard truth is this, we don’t have the roster, yet, to beat bama or uga. but I think we can give them a run for their money, and if we do that the recruits will come. We’re already seeing better talent in this 23 class, and that’s what we need to close the gap. it will be an upset if we beat bama or uga right now, but hopefully soon we’ll have a team that’s expected to win these games. I would only be disappointed if we beat ourselves this weekend, bad penalties, costly mistakes, dropped balls, things like that. having said all that, I know we’re an underdog here, but I really think we have a strong chance of winning straight up.
I am no longer certain just how much credence we should be giving the high school recruiting star-rating services.
Just a few short weeks ago, in the spring and summer, there were plenty of folks on these pages, folks who follow recruiting closely in the recruiting forum, who were saying Florida and LSU continue to have significant roster advantages over our Vols. That they WAY out-talent us.
On the other side of the coin, we were also told that we significantly out-talent Pitt.
Well, Pitt was the closest of those three games. By far.
So what good is following the recruiting stars?
Seems to me, every year there's an Iowa or Mizzou or (this year) Kansas that has an abysmal recruiting ranking history, who find ways to make gold out of dross.
This year, we seem to be one of those teams.
I'm not saying Hendon isn't one of the best QBs in the country--in my estimation he IS the best. And our receivers are right up there with the best in the country, too. And our defensive line. And just one tier below those stand-outs, we also have very good, very solid fellas in all the position groups.
But apparently--especially with all the defections (or discrete invitations to leave) that came with Pruitt's departure--our roster doesn't grade out very high, as a whole.
And yet here we are.
So who is to say, really, whether we have the roster to beat Bama and UGa? Right now, this season, not in the future after more rebuilding, but now?
It has famously been said that it's the Jimmies and Joes, not the Xs and Os. I think it's both. And I think you have to consider the coaching staff AMONG the Jimmies and Joes, if you want to follow that philosophy.
The four most important positions on a college football team today are: QB, head coach, offensive coordinator, and defensive coordinator. After those four, the fifth is probably the place kicker (often the team's highest scorer, though not in Heupel's scheme).
So are we short of the talent needed to challenge the Tide and Dawgs? I don't know. I honestly don't know about all these star ratings and class rankings.
I just know it FEELS like we're in a pretty good position right now to start challenging the best teams in the nation.
Go Vols!