Who is the better Manning?

#76
#76
Who has more MVP s ....





Peyton has my Vote Eli. Has never carried his team like Peyton has
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: 2 people
#79
#79
A little off topic, but does anyone else get a sore throat listening to Chris Berman talk?
 
#82
#82
Here are some clues

Colts without Peyton = 2-14
Peyton = muliple NFL MVP
Peyton = Super Bowl Champ
Peyton = Shatters NFL records

Peyton = SEC champs and NEVER lost to Bamer.

Eli is clutch but this is kind of a meaningless thread.

Like everyone said, throw Peyton on that NY squad and he has at least 2 more rings.

The Colt's are garbage.
 
#85
#85
Watch the ESPN commercial when the Manning family is touring the studio. Peyton kicks Eli's ass. Discussion over!
 
#90
#90
NFL MVP obviously means the NFL's most valuable player. This should answer your question easily.
 
#93
#93
Eli is the better Manning...UT would have 4 NC if Eli would have came here..Peyton never could win the big game....
I'll sit back a watch now LOL
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#97
#97
That is so absurd that people would think eli. It shouldn't even be a question. ***** super bowls. Look at the stats. Better yet, watch the damn film. It's not even close. Eli has a ridiculously good team around him, petting has had nothing. It's really not even close. Even taking an entirely non biased position, just as a NFL fan, it's not even close.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person
#98
#98
n_gerard07 said:
That is so absurd that people would think eli. It shouldn't even be a question. ***** super bowls. Look at the stats. Better yet, watch the damn film. It's not even close. Eli has a ridiculously good team around him, petting has had nothing. It's really not even close. Even taking an entirely non biased position, just as a NFL fan, it's not even close.
Click to expand...

I agree! People put too much emphasis on super bowl wins. I guess Terry Bradshaw is better than peyton then....
 
Last edited:
#99
#99
They are both future Hall of Famers.

Based on how bad the Colts were without Peyton, I have to give him the edge.
 
New posts
You must log in or register to reply here.
Advertisement



Back
Top