Hands down it was the 2001 SEC Championship Game in 2001. We had just beaten Florida in Gainesville to secure the Eastern Division Championship in the game that had been postponed due to 9/11.
UT came into the game needing only to beat LSU, then coached by Saban, to play for the National Championship in the Rose Bowl against Miami. UT would have been the first SEC team to play in the Rose Bowl in 50 years.
Had Fulmer won that game, he would have cemented himself as one of the best coaches ever. As it was, we had a lead at halftime, knocked out LSU's starting QB & RB, & still let Saban come back on Chavis' defense & beat us.
The UT Alumni Association gave out Big Orange roses at the pep rally before the game outside the Georgia Dome. I already had my reservations made in Pasadena & was looking forward to seeing the Pride of the Southland Band march in the Tournament of Roses Parade.
Looking back, Fulmer should have been fired after that loss. The program declined precipitously after that & still hasn't recovered. If Pruitt can't bring it back, Fulmer will be out the door with him, fired for the 2nd time.
Everything was at stake that nite in Atlanta. We had all the tools & talent to play for a National Championship twice in 4 years. We failed miserably.
Had we gotten the chance to play Miami, who's to say we wouldn't have done to them in the 2002 Rose Bowl what we did to them in the 1986 Sugar Bowl? We also lost the chance for another SEC Championship that nite.
All in all, it was the most disappointing loss I've ever witnessed, & I saw my first UT game in person when I was 9 years old in 1966, including many of them on the road, as well as at Neyland.
Another disappointing loss for me was the 1968 Orange Bowl when a furious comeback by Dewey Warren, the Swamp Rat, from a 19-0 halftime deficit against Oklahoma, fell 2 points short when an FG that I still believe was good was called outside the uprights.
The most exciting wins? That 1986 Sugar Bowl win over Miami has to rank high. Another was the 41-14 win with Peyton Manning over Bama in 1995 at Legion Field in Birmingham. Tony Robinson's win at home over #1 Auburn & Bo Jackson, 38-20, is a keeper, too.
What UT loss was the hardest to swallow for you personally during your life?