Which Athlete?

[tidwell]

Peyton Manning.

However, I think Palmer is better in his second year as a starter than Manning was.

Eli or Roethlisberger?

 

[milohimself]

Big Ben... Not as talented but he's a more sound QB at this stage than Eli. But Eli will probably end up better.

Shaun Alexander or Ladanian Tomlinson?

 

[surrealvol]

Tomlinson

Ronde Barber or Tiki Barber?

 

[Vols4life]

Ronde( he plays for my Bucs)

Randy Moss or Chad Johnson

 

[tidwell]

Randy Moss healthy

Dwight Freeney now or Jevon Kearse a few years ago?

 

[MyBloodRunnethOrange]

The Freak

In their prime: Irvin or Rice

 

[tidwell]

Rice

Lawrence Taylor or LaDainian Tomlinson?

 

[surrealvol]

LT

Reggie Bush or Charles White?

 

[surrealvol]

Reggie Bush

Dick Butkus or Ray Nietscke (Spelling?)

 

[volmaniac_2008]

Dick Butkus

Joe Montana or Steve Young

 

[ColtsFan87]

Joe Montana

A-Rod or Derek Jeter

 

[MyBloodRunnethOrange]

A-Rod

Nolan Ryan or Roger Clemens?

 

[bravevol]

Ryan

Furcal or Renteria

 

[tidwell]

Renteria

Adam LaRoche or Julio Franco?

 

[ColtsFan87]

Laroche

Ali or Tyson... both in their prime

 

[surrealvol]

Ali!

Roger Staubach or Brett Favre?

 

[RockyTopEmpire]

Staubach

T.O or Chad Johnson?

 

[bravevol]

Chad

Drew Bennett or Erron Kiney

 

[ColtsFan87]

Bennett

McNair or Culepepper

 

[Jmxvol]

Culpepper

J.J. Redick or Luke Ridenour

 

[ColtsFan87]

Ridenour

Me or jtidell

 

[Hoosier_Vol]

You (Because your a fellow Colts fan)

Ron Artest or Al Harrington?

 

[Jmxvol]

Artest

Dennis Rodman or Bill Cartwright

 

[tidwell]

Rodman

Luc Longley or Tony Kukoc?

 

[Jmxvol]

Luc Longley

Darrell Armstrong or David Wesley