Orange_Crush
Resident windbag genius
- Joined
- Dec 1, 2004
- Messages
- 43,644
- Likes
- 89,869
Oh yes. It always seems comical too me for someone to criticize the "use" of logic, when they can't even account for it. Where does logic exist? How does it exist? It's a metaphysical elephant standing in the corner.
I tried to frame the original question in a way that would stimulate an intellectual conversation.
What went bang? Deals with matter.
Where did it go bang? Deals space.
When did it go bang? Deal with time.
We see how that worked out.
Space, time, matter. Einstein addressed all of these in his theory of relativity.
This begs the question, what are people talking about when they say, "nothing?" ) (Ex Nihilo) Hawking actually proposes (philosophically mind you) that the universe came from NOTHING. Hawking gave credence to Einstein's statement that, "the man of science is a poor philosopher."
Those who seem to be alluding to Hawking also quoted Einstein. I pointed out that it was a misquote and misapplication of Einstein, and Einstein actually said the opposite of what was asserted.
The Hawking reference seems to be referring to a theory that posits a continual expansion/contraction of the universe. It's interesting that the proponents of this theory are the first to admit that the theory is far, far, far from ready for prime time.
The commonly accepted theory, accepted due its successful predictions and account for the universe's uniformity, shows a sudden and immediate creation.
:hi:
