I’m afraid this coming up football season could be a long one. By no means do I think we are bad but the Nico thing is gonna hurt us for sure. No way would we ever want to swap him for that UCLA/App State guy.
Based on? I'm not saying that Aguilar is a top shelf QB. I am saying that he's proven MUCH more on the field than Nico. Nico was pretty mediocre. Maybe all of the behind the scenes drama hurt him. Who knows? But Aguilar IMO is pretty much a wash or maybe a gain vs the way Nico played last year.
Then you have the reports that he threatened to sit out the playoff game to leverage more NIL. You have recent reports that he started skipping team workouts to leverage for more NIL. That's not what you need leading your team or shaping the culture of your locker room. That one thing is a certain improvement with Aguilar.
I do think Nico’s family kinda runs the show but let’s not forget that the offense we were running last year wasn’t the typical Heupel that we know. Maybe he didn’t trust Nico and I mean we made the playoffs so not a terrible decision but we didn’t air that thing out like we are used to. That Oklahoma game for example had us all wondering why we are just playing not to lose when our defense basically won us the game. We took our foot off the gas pedal wayyy too much and I would rather us get out there and air it out. Back when we had Palmer, Jennings, Callaway it always amazed me we didn’t just give them a chance at a jump ball more because they more than not always came down with it. And you have the chance of a PI call. We now don’t have near as much talent but I think Matthews is that guy too so let’s see if we open it up. I’m scared our coach will just run and have them same little passes and screens. I’m thinking about 7 or 8 wins but when Faizon gets here it’s game on and we can get a natty. If he doesn’t watch this season and be like why am I going here
Again, Nico was a mediocre player last year. Sometimes he was flat out bad. You give pretty good reasons for why we should think that... so why do you think losing him damns the season?
Nico is physically talented. Nico's ability to read Ds was suspect and something opponents took advantage of. He supposedly has an elite arm but he couldn't consistently hit the long ball nor did they trust him to throw the sideline screen that made the O so effective with Hooker.
So yes. You are correct. Heupel very much appeared to limit the O playbook to what Nico could do. He also leaned heavily on the run game for the same reason.
Nico still has time. He's young. He's physically gifted. But it takes more than physical gifts to be a championship QB.
The questions for any QB that starts for UT this fall are pretty straight forward and only marginally dependent on having elite physical talent.
1- Can they read D's and run the O?
2- Can the deliver the ball on time in the right place to give the receivers an opportunity to make plays?
3- Can they be a leader and positive force in the locker room? MASSIVELY underestimated by too many. "Good" QBs with GREAT leadership ability are better than what UT got last year from Nico.
4- Can they appreciate and build up the guys around them particularly the OLs? A QB can make all the difference in the world in how confident an OL plays. The line calls matter a lot. But just showing trust matters even more. The RBs last year trusted the OL... praised them. Sampson is said to have been a big leader in the locker room... and the OL blocked well for him.
None of this requires Nico's arm or athleticism. It requires good football intelligence and leadership. Some of us have watched long enough to see undertalented guys like Danny Wuerffel absolutely shred good defenses. Granted there was a ton of talent around Stetson Bennett but his results were MUCH higher than his physical talent would suggest even accounting for the talent.