Top 5 players aren't going to ndsu. A few have gone to TN. And as many that have gone on to do great things have not, and/or transferred out.
Pinning your hopes for the future of the program on recruits (notice that's not "recruiting") individually is what we've done the past 7-8 years.
Let this staff just get guys that fit, want to be here, and see what it looks like in 2-3 years.
For the first time in nearly a decade, I honestly do not care where we wind up in recruiting rankings, or whether or not a guy like nolen comes here. Either way it doesn't mean we're going to instantly get better or never get better.
Mike Ekeler was quoted about recruiting shortly after being hired. He said something to the effect of, there are really only about 3-5 big time difference makers in every class. After that, it's a matter of bringing in guys who fit your culture and your system and developing them within that system.
I think that's what we've been missing. Yeah, we've signed 4* and 5* guys. But we haven't developed them. They don't necessarily fit our system. There hasn't been a good culture.
Heupel can win big at Tennessee by:
A) developing great QBs. It's the most important position in sports. Great QB play can mask a lot of other deficiencies. He has a track record as a great developer of QBs.
B) Identifying guys who fit HIS systems and HIS culture and signing them, whether they're 2*s or 5*s. Hiring coaches who do the same and are on the same page.
C) Developing those guys to be the best they can be within those systems (and again, hiring assistants who do this) and...this is big...having them jell as a team, together, not just as great individuals.
D) Developing the psychological side. A winning attitude and belief that they will win and win together.
Check A through D above and Tennessee will be a big time program again, regardless of where the recruiting services rank us. Of course, eventually, the recruiting rankings will be high simply because recruits will be ranked higher by signing with Tennessee. It's a self-fulfilling thing. (See: Tigers, Clemson)