Let me preface this post by saying that there are few Vol fans more loyal than I am--that's what is driving me to write this post. I graduated from the University of Tennessee, I've had great success in life so far in large part because of the University of Tennessee, and I have tried to repay that over the past few years in the form of donations and volunteer service to the program and the University.
There have been a great many of us on these boards and elsewhere who have been trying to bring attention to a problem that has been growing over the past couple of years with the UT football program. We are frequently called "nega-vols" by the sunshine patrol, written off as malcontents who will criticize anything short of an annual national championship. I hope that people with a more open mind will read these words and at least consider them.
Let's hop in our time machine and take a look at Florida State University for a second. Once a proud powerhouse with two national titles and countless conference championships, since 2001 Florida State University has been on a severe downslope. I lived in Tallahassee from 2000-2005, and there were critics who questioned if perhaps the great Bobby Bowden, the aging architect of the franchise, had lost his magic as a coach--maybe the game had passed him by. But those people were drowned out by the chorus of "look at his winning percentage over the last 15 years, he's a great coach". The program was still reeling in Top-5 recruiting classes at first, with some of the best talent in the nation. Every once in a while, FSU would win a big game on talent alone, and people wondered if maybe they were back. But as the losses piled up over the years, the talent evaporated and the cupboard went empty. Now look at FSU--unable to beat an ass-sorry Clemson team in the season opener, relegated to the mediocrity of just hoping to be in the Top 25. Competing on a national level is just a memory.
Now let's hop back into the time machine and return to present day. I would argue that in 2005 Tennessee slipped onto the same slope. In 2005 we had the disastrous 5-6 season, scapegoated Randy Sanders, and then 2006 was very much the same except that fewer fumbles in key moments of games allowed us to win some tight games that we would have lost the previous year.
We are not so far down the slope that the program cannot be saved. There is still talent on this team. A coach like Urban Meyer or Steve Spurrier could compete for a national championship with our talent. So the question is this--do we continue on our current path, allowing our appreciation for a man who has brought us great success in the past to drag this program off the national radar, or do we move forward with a coach who understands the modern game and can take our existing talent and return the program to prominence?
I'm willing to bet that if FSU's AD could get a time machine to allow him to go back to 2003 and bring in a more modern coach, he'd do it in a cocaine heartbeat. We have that time machine, and I pray that Mike Hamilton uses it at the end of this season if not sooner.