I don’t think it’s a bad hire. He’s been a very good position coach for a number of years now under 3 different head coaches. The fact that both Mularkey and Vrabel opted to retain him says quite a bit.
He’s also, perhaps most importantly, more familiar with Mariota than anyone, having literally coached in the same offense as him since he entered the league.
I’m pretty indifferent for the most part. It’s definitely not a splash, but we got one of those last year and it didn’t work out. Unless a proven, established OC was available, an up and coming position coach was likely anyway. Might as well be our own.